ATD2013 Final: Pittsburgh AC vs. Montreal Canadiens
View Single Post
05-19-2013, 06:52 PM
I voted for Kodos
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: West Egg, New York
Originally Posted by
Bring Back Scuderi
I think Kapustin's offense is impressive and he apparently could work the boards, but is his offense that much better than Larmer's?
Yes, it probably is. Steve Larmer is a glue guy, and he scores like...a glue guy. A good one, but still, he's not going to be mistaken for a primary scorer anytime soon. Here's where Larmer falls in VsX among RWs:
Dit Clapper #
Steve Larmer is, among other things, behind Tony Amonte on this list - the same Amonte who is playing RW on Montreal's 3rd line. But we're comparing Larmer to Kapustin, a guy who led the Red Army team in goals-per-game for most of the 70's, and put up remarkably similar numbers to Alexander Yakushev on the Soviet national team. Kapustin led the world championships in goalscoring twice, and was a three time IIHF all-star at LW, beating out Valeri Kharlamov in 1978 and tying with Bill Barber in 1982...on the strength of his offense. He's also playing on a line that very closely reproduces the one on which he skated for those old Red Army teams, with the exact same right winger, and much better version of his old center. Yeah, I think there's a sizeable offensive gap between them.
If I had to take a guess, I'd probably put Kapustin's offense on about the level of a guy like Alexander Mogilny. Others may disagree, but that's my best estimation of his talent, and I'd be positively shocked if he were lower than Kovalev. If we were asking the same question vis-á-vis Mogilny, would there be any doubt that yes, in fact, there is a sizeable offensive difference between he and Larmer? The offensive gap between Kapustin and Larmer is probably bigger, in fact, than the one between Roenick and Morris (who would have to be at the Hawerchuk level offensively to equal the gap here), but Larmer is better defensively than Roenick, so that evens things out. The Montreal forwards are also quite a bit more physical, but at any rate, I think it's pretty much a pick 'em between these pairs.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Sturminator