NYR Top Defensemen of All-Time (Rules & Preliminary Discussion)
View Single Post
06-03-2013, 06:16 PM
Join Date: Jun 2009
The only argument McDonagh has over Staal is how good last year was (he led the league in Defensive Point Shares). Staal and Girardi both have relative longevity and high DPS for the time that they've played. Even so, they only have one ASG each, and generally haven't been regarded as top tier defensemen (they're definitely a step down).
Actually, I was quite dismissive of Colville earlier, but depending on how you weight AST selections, I could conceivably see him ranked above any of our current defensemen.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Greg02