Is Henrik Lundqvist An HOFer?
View Single Post
06-06-2013, 02:44 PM
Join Date: Jul 2011
Originally Posted by
Negative, especially not in the context of what we're talking about. Literally, an entire career perception is hinged on a single playoff run. A pretty unremarkable one at that.
Well, it was remarkable for its pronounced ups and downs.
That's why I maintain that it's dangerous territory to start anointing players after two, non-consecutive (no less) seasons of play. It was a slippery slope then and shortly thereafter my fears were confirmed.
The lowest save percentage Thomas had in a series was 0.916. Let's compare that to other "lowest" series for recent Smythe winners:
Quick: 0.939 (vs Phx)
Ward: 0.901 (vs BUF)
Giguere: 0.910 (vs NJ)
Roy: 0.898 (vs VAN)
I don't see how Thomas' playoffs can be considered to be remarkably up-and-down (besides, what you're essentially doing is reducing an already small sample size to something even smaller). Quick is really a massive anomaly with regards to how stable his save percentage was between series.
This just seems like grasping at straws.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by GuineaPig