View Single Post
Old
06-15-2013, 11:31 AM
  #325
Monctonscout
Monctonscout
 
Monctonscout's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 33,697
vCash: 500
Quote:
Originally Posted by hockeyfan2k11 View Post
I wouldn't want any of them for 6 years. Scuderi and Ferrence are proven and bring a lot more than Gorges. Oduya brings more offensively, but if you want to say Gorges is better, then that's fine.

So...Gorges is great, Subban is great, Markov is great, Drewiskie is great, Tinordi is great, Emelin is great, Diaz is great (remember we wanted to trade PK?). Yet when we talk about Price, our D stinks.

Gorges has played 20+ minutes the last 5 years, how much more "proven" do you want from a player? Plus he is 28, a lot younger than those two meaning 5 more years of contract is less risky than for a 34-35 year old.

What "more" do Scuderi and Ference bring? Scuderi the last 2 years has 21 ponts and -13, Gerence had 37 points and +15 and Gorges 25 points and +18. Oduya 30 points and +6. Size wise he is bigger than Ference and a bit smaller than Scuderi.

Saying those guys are clearly better is BS. You can argue small details either way but he's at least on par with the majority of those guys.

Your last paragraph is ridiculous.

I said Gorges was a good/solid #3-4, how you assiociate that with "great" is mind boggling. I don't know of too mnay #3-04 guys going into the hall of fame, great d-men are usually #1 or at worst #2 on powerhouse teams. Drewiske is a dependable #7 guy, gain, not sure on which planet taht equates to "great", Tinordi has excellent upside but based on his play so far in the NHl he's been far far from great, still a work in progress. Diaz, same as Gorges, good/solid #3-4, again, not sure where you get "great" out of that?

Monctonscout is offline   Reply With Quote