Thread: Proposal: Rangers/Hurricanes
View Single Post
07-09-2013, 04:57 PM
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Da Big Apple
Country: United States
Posts: 13,467
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by bleedgreen View Post
I always thought the brothers angle was way overplayed. Rutherford loves the staals and will do anything to get them all, I've never been convinced the brothers had that big an itch to play together. Sounds like Eric gave Jordan a nudge to get him on board, but I doubt Marc is aching to move to Carolina. They probably all enjoy creating their own identities away from each other. Sound like Eric and Jordan are very close as well, like best buds close. I don't know that Marc is that joined at the hip as jordan, but I'm obviously not a staal family member so who knows. I'm just not convinced when Marc goes fa that he's gonna run our way and for a fair price. I think his not being 100% may make him easier to pry from the rangers, but again who know?

I think he'll have great value to the canes even at 80%. He's a strong stay at home d, we need that. I think it's weird to have all four brothers, kinda sideshow gimmicky. I'd rather find someone else.

Faulk for staal just isn't paying attention to reality. We need more Faulk, and that's why we like one out for the other just creates the same situation we already have. It doesn't help us any. Collecting a staal doesn't justify it.

Bold: never said 1 for 1. I said Staal + for Faulk +.
Could be Staal + Girardi + X for Faulk + Y
Girardi = RD replaces RD lost, so you gain a premo D.

Of course, that said, in the above equation X is minimal for balance and Y is substantial.
I think there is a deal to be made; I just can't pour over both rosters and fine tune a close to exact win win match, but I think there is a combo that works.

You would get a jolt on added merchandising, buzz factor, etc.
The cap hit in this case is you get what you pay for. If they were = # of years, then maybe much much closer salary. I'm not saying you cripple your club to make it happen, but I believe whether it was Alou/Dimaggio bros in baseball, or other examples, you'd get some increased $$$ for 3-5 yrs.

bernmeister is offline   Reply With Quote