NYR Forward Chemistry 2012-13
View Single Post
08-26-2013, 09:22 AM
Join Date: Sep 2008
Originally Posted by
It is generally said a good top-6 player should average at least 1.8 P/60.
Last season among forwards who played in at least 20 games
1.8 P/60 ranked the player 131st = Doan
1.65 P/60 ranked the player 160th = Callahan
5 on 5
Doan had ~725 minutes, 24 pts =.0331 pts per 5 on 5 minute
Callahan had ~708 minutes, 20 pts = .0282 pts per 5 on 5 minute
If they both played the average minutes between them = 716
Doan 23.69 pts
Callahan 20.19 pts
So Doan as a 23-24 point scorer 5 on 5 is a good top 6 forward but Callahan as a 20-21 point player is not?
Lets say its a full season 1200 minutes 5 on 5
Doan 39.72 pts
Callahan 33.84 pts
~6 points differential, does 6 even strength points over a full season really put one player in the "good" category while putting the other in the less than good over a full season?
Do not mean to say I do not like your chart, I think it's pretty cool, just don't know if the small range between the players in terms of points per 60 is really that big of a deal.
Last edited by Off Sides: 08-26-2013 at
View Public Profile
Off Sides's albums
Find More Posts by Off Sides