Thread: Proposal: Vancouver - Philadelphia
View Single Post
08-28-2013, 01:43 PM
What's your point?
Azir's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2013
Country: United States
Posts: 5,425
vCash: 500
Originally Posted by Spice Trader View Post
Is Nazim Kadri a PPG player? He has shown it as often as JV has for the same amount of time.

Before people go all wonky on me I don't think NK is as good as JV.

Couple facts tho.

It is widely agreed that D and centers are the most valuable position. Wingers being the least valuable.

If your going to call JV a top line winger you have to call Edler a #1 dman. there is not 29 better Dmen and ill agree there is not 29 better RW's.

Value is equal. IF the respective fan bases want to keep there player that's fine. But the difference is sure as ***** not two firsts.
That is true in terms of trade value it goes:


JV is a better player and has more value that Edler but, I guess the notion that Defenseman are more valuable than a winger is true so that sort of makes it closer. But, I still think that JV's value is still higher nonetheless. I think a fair trade in terms of value would be Edler and a 1st for Voracek. Vancouver will most likely have a pick in the 20's, so it does not carry the same weight as a lottery pick. However, I can not see either of these two team be inclined to do a trade such as that.

Azir is offline   Reply With Quote