Niedermayer vs Chara
View Single Post
09-30-2013, 02:19 PM
Zemgus Da Gawd
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Upstate NY
Originally Posted by
The comparison of Scott's last 5 seasons with the Devil's compared to his next 5 with the Ducks shows that his ES scoring went down slightly but his PP scoring doubled.
NJ GP- 366 P-199 ES-131 (0.36) PP-65 (0.18)
AHN GP-371 P-264 ES-121 (0.33) PP-135 (0.36)
So Niedermayer's overall point totals were hurt because the Devils were an uncharacteristically bad PP team relative to where they were in the standings**? Nieds was a top 5 ES scorer in 98 and 99*, had top 5 worthy ES P/G stats the next two seasons, had another top 5 year in 2003, and led the league in ES points the year he won the Norris.
Combine that with his flashy end-to-end style, the Devils prominence, and Nieds' minute totals, and it's pretty easy to see how he was considered a "top offensive defenseman" before he started finishing higher in points.
*6-8 way tie for fourth.
**they were and they weren't, I'm fact checking as I go. Nied's production in 98 and 99 was commendable, and came on teams whose best PP forwards were Holik and Sykora. The unit then seems to flow through the A line for the next couple seasons without much change in either goals-for or efficiency before taking huge steps back in 02 and 03.
TDMM/Devils fans, are the numbers lying here? Did the structural focus of the NJD power play shift away from Niedermayer as it seems to have? Or was he always just a cog in a machine that found better players for his job?
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by struckbyaparkedcar