View Single Post
11-15-2013, 07:00 AM
Error 503 Service
Watsatheo's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Toronto
Country: Canada
Posts: 34,754
vCash: 883
Originally Posted by ECWHSWI View Post
and so far he's playing well enough for a 3M player...

so, what's your point ?
I think it's whether he can maintain it over 82 games. After all, he hasn't been playing ~20min/game more than 42 games and had a serious injury that may or may not be a long term issue. Same questions for Emelin.

I guess it's interesting Bergevin is willing to still take that approach to re-sign despite what happened with Desharnais. Perhaps he's strong enough on his philosophy that one error won't rattle him.

Originally Posted by Monctonscout View Post
Teams that have sucess extend the players they like and want to keep before the cost rises. People complain about the Gorges contract, well it was at the 11th hour(though his injury was a factor) and he ended up about 500k more/year than it would have been 6 months earlier.
Hopefully you have a link or something to back that claim up or else it looks like you made up stuff as proof to strengthen your argument especially considering Gorges was extended mid-season:

He was playing 20-23 min/game, shutdown top pairing ES D minutes, top PK unit minutes on one of leagues best PKs, 'blocking machine' type name-reputation, etc for 4 straight seasons heading to UFA. I highly doubt this fellow would have approved much lower. Diaz is rumoured to get something close and he hasn't shown to be close to effective as Gorges at his best with a fraction of the experience.

If you want to speculate that perhaps the Habs offered him unreasonable term (especially considering shelf life of his player type) for a lower cap hit, then I can see the logic. Your claim that he'd have taken ~.5M discount had the Habs attempted to sign him earlier on the other hand, not sure it holds any basis.

Last edited by Watsatheo: 11-15-2013 at 07:22 AM.
Watsatheo is offline