Trade Thread Part XI: New year...no trades.
View Single Post
01-05-2014, 01:01 PM
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: New York, NY
Originally Posted by
If we give Callahan that money it will absolutely be a Drury situation. They're the same player. Drury was a bigger scorer than Cally before we paid him. Cally misses 10-20 games every year with injuries already. We will end up hating Cally before his extension is up. Stepan is like a more skilled, less gritty Callahan as well.
Girardi is a different story. He will slow down and become a middle pairing RHD and not the top pairing guy but he will still be serviceable and a good leader/mentor for young D we bring in/develop over the years. He never misses games, or even shifts, with injuries and I don't think he'll suddenly break down and become injury prone. Even if he starts missing 2-5 every year, that's nothing; significantly less than Callahan has missed very year already. He'll be reliable for top four minutes for another 5 years, I have little doubt.
totally agree, my comments above are more geared to g as well.. I want him around for the rest of his career.. bc hes not replaceable for what he brings..
and in terms of callahan i want him, but i wouldnt pay him the long term as i would g.. to me we have other leaders on the team that can bring that skill set to their roles like g, staal, even stepan
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by dethomas07