GDT HFD-Portland 20/1 -07
View Single Post
01-21-2007, 05:53 AM
Join Date: Apr 2004
Darn I went to sleep after 2, looks like I missed a really good 3rd...
Originally Posted by
Ola, how does Liffiton and Girardi look to you.
Liffiton looks like he have regressed. He came in as a 20 y/o with a edge and smooth skating. Moved well laterally for a guy with his size. Though he didn't really play well, but with his raw tools I hoped that he might improve his overall game.
Now he have kind of lost that little mobility he had. At the AHL level, compared to many D's on other teams, he is a pretty solid depth guy, no doubt, but I don't see him making it to the NHL.
On Girardi, he plays a good hockey game. I have never really become a fan of him though. With Lampman you got that great poise with the puck at the AHL level. With Pöck you got his really good offensive tools. Though with Girardi, you got no aspects like that, just always a solid 60 minutes.
Not beeing a great passer in the NHL today basically makes you a liability. Before some teams didn't even want their D's to pass the puck, like Anaheim and Calgary. Now a pass out of your own end that don't reach a teammate will result in a scoring chance against. If you aren't a good playing D, I think you really must stand out in other aspects to be attractive at the NHL level.
At the same time, Kaspar for example aren't dooing any of that. Pöck when struggling is allot worse then a Girardi who struggles.
In the end though, I think I would like to see Lampman get a real shot. Its like, if we had one of Kaspar and Pöck right now, I am sure Renney would try both Girardi and Lampman allot more. But when we have both, he don't look past them.
The problem with Bruce Lampman is that while he got a pretty good skill level, he is a swift skater, decent along the boards and 1 on 1, a good passer and have a decent shot, just a solid 2-way D, its his poise that really stands out, and when he have been given a chance in the NHL he have always been hit by the big shiver. Thats kind of a anticlimax. Though if he somehow could survive his first 5 games in the NHL, I wonder if he wouldn't be the best fit next to Rachunek in this org.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Ola