Thread: Prospect Info: David Musil vs. Oscar Klefbom
View Single Post
Old
02-17-2014, 10:09 PM
  #41
raab
Where's the Hart?
 
raab's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 7,195
vCash: 580
Quote:
Originally Posted by topchowda View Post
17 points in 65 games. Wow, I really missed that. Are we now attributing Stanley Cup wins to crappy players? Trevor Lewis and Dwight King also won the Stanely cup as passengers. Penner was also along for the ride

Penner has only started putting up points on a stacked Anaheim team with 2 great linemates.

If he had not being traded, he would have continued to be lazy and on the decline. In 2011 or 2012 when his value is at an all time low (he would have been on a much worse EDM team), Oiler fans would be demanding him to be traded, and we would have received a 3rd for him.

Penner was also traded while we were in a rebuilding phase, hence trading ageing players for prospects. If Klefbom has not gotten injured in the SEL last season he would have absolutly been in the NHL right now, and all would have been on plan. Instead he unfortunately got injured, so his NHL debut is delayed

Instead we received a 1st who turned into Klefbom, a prospect continually rated as a top 30 NHL prospect, who has been playing great in the AHL.

A potential top 4 or top 2 D is needed on the Oilers much more than a lazy, 30 goal scorer who wouldnt even been around anymore
Fixed, we easily lost the Penner deal. I have no clue how anyone can say we didn't. Can you imagine if we had kept him and still drafted RNH. Theres no way we would have been last in the league and get Yakupov. Also probably could have sheltered RNH between Hemsky and Penner and brought him up properly. If we had kept him and resigned him our Roster realistically could have looked like this considering we most likely pick lower in the Yakupov draft and last years.

Hall-RNH-Eberle
Penner-Gagner-Hemsky
Perron-Gordon-UFA/Hendricks
Gazdic-Smyth-Jones

Ference-Trouba(9th pick in 2012)
Marincin-Petry
Belov-Schultz

raab is offline   Reply With Quote