: News Article:
Edmonton Oilers: Wait and See at 2C
View Single Post
08-02-2014, 01:41 PM
Join Date: Apr 2005
Originally Posted by
Up the Irons
you are right. the only thing 'proven' is that Gagner is pretty much useless at a 2C at the NHL level.
again, a useless career NHL starting centre.
bottom line is Gagner had 7 years to prove he was a 2C and all he did was prove he isn't. The only way Gagner works as a 2C is if the wingers are allstars, but you could say that about anyone, including me.
in one measely month Arco did enough to convince MacT that he was a better option at C than Gagner
. that's all there is too it.
Arco as a 2C = probably not good enough
however, Arco as a 2C > Gagner as a 2C.
Explain then why Arco was demoted for the rest of the season then. Gagner had a bad year due to injury. Lets not extrapolate from that that he's useless. Virtually nobody was saying that the year before. I suspect nobody will be saying it in a years time.
If MacT was convinced of anything in such a brief sample he's a worse manager than I had thought. Right now he's convincing me that he's headed into a season with a disaster at Center this year instead of the disaster in net. The common thread being entering into seasons with such obvious lineup flaws.
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by Replacement*