View Single Post
03-05-2004, 11:17 PM
Join Date: Jan 2004
Originally Posted by
To Vancouver: Keith Carney, Rob Niedermayer and Chicago 3rd in 04
To Anahiem: Eric Daze, Feder Federov and Steve McCarthy
To Chicago: Petr Sykora, Jarkko Ruutu and Brandon Reid
This deal makes no sense whatsoever, for a variety of reasons. The Canucks give up very little (Reid, Fedorov and Ruutu) to get two good players and a mid-round pick. Chicago makes out all right, but I doubt they'd want to move McCarthy. The Ducks get ripped off big time as they lose Carney, Niedermayer and Sykora and only get a injury-prone, soft winger in Daze, questionable prospect in Fedorov and McCarthy who is a good young defenseman.
How would this deal work, anyways?
I think that a deal is a possibility between our two teams, but I think that Vishnevski and Carney are unlikely to be possibilities as the Ducks would want a lot for them (rightly so). Niedermayer would be a good addition, but are the Ducks willing to move him?
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by bandwagon