Here's something to consider... Lupul is signed for two more years. Vish is a RFA that isn't signed for next year.
Those are nice young guns though. Feds is popular, not to us, but to the rest of the NHL... plus 91 is a cool #. Have you ever thought of Nieds?
Myself... i got a third early in the season and i put #8 Ozo on it. Ozo is an all-star D-man that's got lots of offense! That and not many people actually have Ozo on the new thirds. Everyone's got either JS, Feds, Sykora or Rooch.
But i believe Lupul will turn out like Rick Nash, but 20-30% less production than Nash in his 2nd year. I say get a Lupul one! But if i were you... i'd just wait and see if Getzlaf makes the team. Cuz i like him more than Lupul b/c of his energy and same mind set with Rob Nieds. ( you had to watch some preseason games this past year to know ).
so my vote is for you to wait if you really want Getzlaf.