Tough one. The best I can do is select one or two from each position and widdle it down from there:
Forwards: Zetterberg or Iginla, tremendous scoring forwards with tons of leadership and experience
Defense: Weber or J-Bo, I'd probably prefer Weber given that he's a bit more physical and I believe younger and with a higher ceiling
Goalie: Luongo is probably my choice, although with a better defensive coach/system I think our goalies look better than they do this year.