Duncan Keith vs Marc-Edouard Vlasic

[Taupy]

Who do you like better? How do they compare skill-wise? Who will improve the more in the next 2-3 years? What are their weakness?

[Dark Shadows]

This is grossly unfair to Vlasic, who is still young and improving every year.

At this point, Keith is WELL ahead of Vlasic and I expect in 3 years for Vlasic to be about what Keith is right now.

Defensively, they are comparable(Edge Keith), and Keith is better offensively and has ridiculous endurance.

[Redwingsfan]

This is unfair to Vlasic.. Keith is a top 5 d-man in the league (IMO).. I think Vlasic is amazing, but this really isn't close at this point..

[bigwillie]

Right now? Keith's definitely a notch or two (or three....) above.

Future? Keith's just about to enter his prime. Vlasic's still only 21, so he has a little more room to grow.

Still, both are fantastic shutdown defenseman with underrated offensive games, and are two of my favorite players. I'll take either, but right now Keith is superior.

[Paul4587]

Keith and it's not even close at this point.

[SixthSens]

Right now, Keith.

[tony d]

Duncan Keith

[Luigi Lemieux]

keith is close to superstar status if he isn't there already. easy poll.

[The Big Swede]

Keith is much better at this point but,I expect Vlasic to catch up in the new few years

[Celestial Black]

Keith.

[Teemu]

Alright, mercy rule.