My vote goes to the Yes We Can idea because I'm a big fan of the idea of having an avatar theme with individualized text or phrases for each player. Gives you a chance to be witty, plus it allows people to use the same player as someone else and not have the same exact avatar.
Sorry MJr, definitely not feeling the Little Bit O'Luck idea, mainly because I freaking hate those commercials. And the early designs have way too much white space, they're just boring.
Uh heh, I see some people are diggin' the "Little bit of [Insert player nickname here]" while others are not. I understand the need for the big glasses, but the dude in the original photo is 1. at an angle, so it looks strange on most of the players. And 2. looks a little strange cutting his glasses/eyes out and pasting it on our players' faces, rendering them unrecognizable. Trust me, I've tried it. Anyway, if anyone else IS successful in putting those glasses on the players, let me know. And also, if anyone else has any other player requests for one, let me know. Thanks!