i think kevin hatcher vs. mike green would be a reasonable poll
and even then..................Hatcher never led defensemen in points
he was alright, maybe even good at best. History seems to point towards his brother Derian as the better defenseman, and as I am writing this I am thinking that Derian definitely was the better player.
I'll take Chara with the flu over Kevin "I'm 6'4" 230lbs. but don't utilize my size" Hatcher