Absolutely not, Visnovsky is definitely better defensively, while Streit probably has the edge offensively as of right now.
It's pretty close, but Visnovsky's defense wins it.
The Rangers couldn't, and wouldn't even think about trading Staal for Visnovsky. You want Staal? The only way he'd be leaving is as part of a package for a guy like Phaneuf or Weber.
Realistically, if I'm the Rangers, because of cap concerns... I'd offer
Rozsival/Redden (pick one), Sanguinetti/McDonagh (pick one), and a 1st.
Rozsival or Redden would have to be included in the deal, otherwise the Rangers couldn't do it capwise.
Do not even mention Staal's name in a Ranger's deal, that guy is Jesus there. I like the kid, but I feel the Ranger's overrate him quite a bit. But that's OK, he's there guy and it's OK to love your own team's players.
Uhhhh, I'm not sure where to start on this one..... Brutal proposal from an Oilers fan that doesnt address any of the teams current needs.
S.Kostitsyn would make the Oilers but not the Habs?....right. Quinn is going to bench Stone, Jacques, and/or Stortini? The Oilers would be dressing a roster softer than an ice capades cast. Not to mention that the Oilers get robbed for Visnovsky, and Cogliano
Originally Posted by danaluvsthekings
I'd edit or delete that proposal before Oilers fans see it and come at you.
Well he must have read it before posting it. Brutal....just brutal.