Proposal: Montreal-Columbus

[Bibeen]

TO MTL :
R.J. Umberger
Jared Boll

TO CBS :
Andrei Kostitsyn
Tom Pyatt
Mathieu Carle

[Halifaxhab]

while Umberger is exactly the player Mtl needs, I hope you change your name and hid any valuables because, while there may not be legions of them, Columbus fans have a MASSIVE man crush on him....good luck

[ccgg]

Originally Posted by Bibeen

TO MTL :
R.J. Umberger
Jared Boll

TO CBS :
Andrei Kostitsyn
Tom Pyatt
Mathieu Carle

1- Remove Boll, Carle and Pyatt.
2- Add a good thing from Habs to CBJ.

[Timeless Winter]

As much as I love Andrei Kostitsyn as a CBJ fan, you won't get RJ for him.

RJ received stitches last night during the game vs the Kings, came back later and was diving around blocking shots to make sure the game went to OT.

[Gagnefan924]

Rj isnt getting traded....its stupid to even ask.

[Double-Shift Lassé]

For what it's worth.

Wish I had a mountaintop from which to scream this: #CBJ W R.J. Umberger is not going to be traded. He means WAY too much to #CBJ.

http://twitter.com/Aportzline

[Roadman]

Maybe not stupid.

But it is fruitless.

[Richiebottles]

Tom Useless pyatt and Carle who gets passed by Nash on D. Don't think the jackets are gonna be happy.

[TaketheCannoli]

Originally Posted by Bibeen

TO MTL :
R.J. Umberger
Jared Boll

TO CBS :
Andrei Kostitsyn
Tom Pyatt
Mathieu Carle

Counter:

To Columbus

Tomas Plekanic
Mathieu Carle

To Montreal:

Kristian Huselius
Jared Boll
Derek Dorsett
Andrew Murray
Nick Holden


Why? Columbus does this to get a center for Nash now that Brassard is injured.

Montreal does this to get some scoring from Huselius, some badly needed sandpaper from Boll, Murray and Dorsett, plus a solid prospect in Holden to replace Carle in Hamilton.

[Richiebottles]

No way we give Turtleneck unless we get Nash in return.

[TaketheCannoli]

Originally Posted by Richiebottles

No way we give Turtleneck unless we get Nash in return.

Oh, you don't want quantity for quality?

[Clipitar]

Originally Posted by leek

Oh, you don't want quantity for quality?

Yeah, I had seen a CBJ fan here wanting Plek++ for Umberger.

I thought it was cute.

[Gagnefan924]

Originally Posted by Clipitar

Yeah, I had seen a CBJ fan here wanting Plek++ for Umberger.

I thought it was cute.

Yea I saw a MTL fan wanting Umberger for some scrubs...thought it was hilarious.

[Bibeen]

AK is very similar to RJ Umberger in stat so why my trade proposal is stupid?

[LostMyGlasses*]

Originally Posted by Bibeen

AK is very similar to RJ Umberger in stat so why my trade proposal is stupid?

Yikes.

[Ludicrous Speed]

Originally Posted by Bibeen

AK is very similar to RJ Umberger in stat so why my trade proposal is stupid?

RJ means more to us than stats, not to mention he's out-producing AK.

[Blind Gardien]

The Umberger-to-Habs dream has been shot down frequently enough before. One can search for past threads if one is interested.

/thread