It broke the tie in one division and created a tie in the other.
Just flip a coin. It's the MLD, so nobody should care anyway.
If you really want to break the tie, here's a suggestion. Head to head would be used in the NHL, so use that here. Look at where the two tied teams voted each other. Assuming they voted each other in different spots, just take the one who was voted lower by the other team.
Example: Team A and B are tied.
Team A voted team B 2nd
Team B voted team A 4th
should have sent them to Billy, as it was he who was collecting for the division. I asked that they go to me as well, just so whoever sees them first can post the final results. You only sent to me, and since I was already in bed, I never got them until now, and mark voted and looks like just his was counted... which makes sense.
Buzz Boll (GAR) - Jimmy Gardner (BEL) - Vincent Lukac (NNW)
Billy McGimsie (EHW) - Jason Spezza (MTL) - Bob McDougall (PHI)
Anders Kallur (PHI) - Murray Craven (HFX) - Mike Murphy (PIT)
Michal Pivonka (PHI) - Terry Crisp (GAR) - Mike Bullard (HFX)
Dutch Reibel (DET)
Tom Bladon (NNW) - Jim McKenny (HFX)
Warren Godfrey (NNY) - Bill Brydge (NNW)
Mike O'Connell (EHW) - Sergei Babinov (DET)
Jack Portland (REG)
Billy Nicholson (REG)
Kirk McLean (BEL)
Charles Tobin (REG)
Coddy Winters (WAR)
what the hell, why not? everyone here still received at least two votes (most at least three), so let's recognize them as well.
MLD 2011 Third All-Star Team
Coach: Emile Francis (MTL)
Assistant Coach: Brian Kilrea (BEL)
Tom Hooper (WAR) - Skene Ronan (BEL) - Scott Mellanby (WAR)
Steve Payne (TBY) - Bob Gracie (REG) - Guy Chouinard (NNY)
Sami Kapanen (EHW) - Todd Marchant (NNW) - Keith Crowder (BRN)
Vladimir Golikov (DET) - Larry Patey (EHW) - Jorgen Pettersson (BEL)
Nick Mickoski (EHW), Jeff Carter (EHW)
Brian Campbell (EHW) - Al Hamilton (TBY)
Bob Murdoch (HFX) - Bob Armstrong (REG)
Alex Smith (PHI) - Bob Trapp (PIT)
Brad Marsh (GAR)