It's close between Pasquale and JST. It's also hard to compare goaltenders and forwards. My probelm is that I think both of these guys will play in the NHL in depth positions. Pasquale will be back-up in 2-3 years while JST will be scoring 10-15 goals and providing toughness and grit on the third line.
So what's more valuable a backup tender or an effective third liner?
I went with JST this time. I think this coming season will be a breakout year in the NCAA for him.