I think Evander Kane should have been the Jets rep in the ASG.
Sometimes it comes down to which positions are available to be filled, not who's the best player. Every team had to be represented, and it can get tricky.
Even if Sharp were healthy he may not have made it. The way I see it Kane and Toews are going no matter what, the AS game is about marketing the league and they are two of the biggest names and Kane is one of the best Americans. Hossa deserves it over Sharp, so then for him to make it you would have to eliminate a forward from another team, but make sure they are all still represented, which is easier said than done. The AS game is nice and fun for the fans, but it means little in terms of player evaluation, often deserving players get left behind because of circumstance.