Goal: Selanne OT vs Wings, a close 2nd would be the B. Ryan spinorama.
Save: Couldn't think of one, but Jiggy in the 2003 SC playoffs was great.
Game: Game 5 of 2007 SCF. I was at the game. Amazing experience.
Pass: Bertuzzi spinorama to Perry to Niedermayer back in '08.
Moment: The CUP!
Fight: Beauch vs. Kopecky in 2008, or numerous fights of the Grimson reaper.
Hit: Ryan v. Moller
I guess I'd be looking at mostly the last 5 years, though we were largely successful in those last 5 years, and thus have more to provide.
At least 2 people posted things I mentioned 2.5 years ago