Value of: Doug Murray

[4thLinePlug]

What would you guys give up for him? He is a great shot blocker, hard hitter and plays excellent defence.

Sharks need a top 6 forward + a 3rd liner for him. Is he worth this?

Sharks do this because of Petreckis progression. He plays similar to Murray, but is a better rounded player

[LeafsFan2342]

MacArthur + Armstrong + 2nd

for Murray + late pick

[Dr Awesome]

Murray could be welcome addition to many teams but he wont return top six plus third liner.

[DekeLikeYouMeanIt]

Originally Posted by CloweForbidzYou

What would you guys give up for him? He is a great shot blocker, hard hitter and plays excellent defence.

Sharks need a top 6 forward + a 3rd liner for him. Is he worth this?

Sharks do this because of Petreckis progression. He plays similar to Murray, but is a better rounded player

Are you giving up on the playoffs? Because Murray is a solid shut-down D and I think the Sharks can't afford to let him go.

[Forsead]

Mtl could probably give something like Kostitsyn + Darche he his exactly what Habs blueline need.

[Gliff]

I dont think he is worth it unless that top 6 is boarder line. Not legit.

[CarvinSigX]

D'agostini
Ponich/Edmundson

[Lehner]

Originally Posted by CloweForbidzYou

What would you guys give up for him? He is a great shot blocker, hard hitter and plays excellent defence.

Sharks need a top 6 forward + a 3rd liner for him. Is he worth this?

Sharks do this because of Petreckis progression. He plays similar to Murray, but is a better rounded player

Remember you have Havlat still, he will be back wont he?

[IBLeaf*]

Mac + Armstrong?

[Valic]

Hemsky and Belanger!

[BigDmitriy]

Originally Posted by LeafsFan2342

MacArthur + Armstrong + 2nd

for Murray + late pick

I'd probably do that? What about the rest of us Sharks fans?

Marleau-Thornton-Pavelski
Clowe-Couture-MacArthur
McGinn-Handzus-Armstrong

[LeafsFan2342]

Originally Posted by BigDmitriy

I'd probably do that? What about the rest of us Sharks fans?

Marleau-Thornton-Pavelski
Clowe-Couture-MacArthur
McGinn-Handzus-Armstrong

Or just dont give Leafs a pick and take a 3rd instead of the 2nd

[IBLeaf*]

Originally Posted by BigDmitriy

I'd probably do that? What about the rest of us Sharks fans?

Marleau-Thornton-Pavelski
Clowe-Couture-MacArthur
McGinn-Handzus-Armstrong

Take out the 2nd and I'd do it.

[BigDmitriy]

Originally Posted by LeafsFan2342

Or just dont give Leafs a pick and take a 3rd instead of the 2nd

I'd prefer that.

Take out the 2nd and I'd do it.

Not as good as with the 3rd, but I'd do it too.

[IBLeaf*]

Originally Posted by BigDmitriy

I'd prefer that.



Not as good as with the 3rd, but I'd do it too.

I was thinking the Sharks add a pick.

Toronto
Clarke MacArthur
Colby Armstrong

San Jose
Douglas Murray
3rd '12

Sounds good to me. Top 6 forward and a 3rd liner for a second pairing D and a pick.

Make a proposal thread?

[oilersfan87]

Hemsky + Peckham?

[BigDmitriy]

Originally Posted by jpallday

I was thinking the Sharks add a pick.

Toronto
Clarke MacArthur
Colby Armstrong

San Jose
Douglas Murray
3rd '12

Sounds good to me. Top 6 forward and a 3rd liner for a second pairing D and a pick.

Make a proposal thread?

Maybe...I don't think we have a 3rd '12 though, so maybe 3rd '13?

EDIT: made a proposal thread, but made it a 3rd in '13