Proposal: A few oiler moves

[moneygoalie31]

TO Toronto: PRV and ANH 2nd To EDM: Luke Schenn
TO Nashville:Hemsky TO EDM: Ellis or Blum and 1st
TO Philly: Smid and Edm 2nd to EDM: Brayden Schenn

Mabey way off but I think the value is there in all deals.

[Marlo Stanfield]

Originally Posted by moneygoalie31

TO Toronto: PRV and ANH 2nd To EDM: Luke Schenn
TO Nashville:Hemsky TO EDM: Ellis or Blum and 1st
TO Philly: Smid and Edm 2nd to EDM: Brayden Schenn

Mabey way off but I think the value is there in all deals.

Don't see Toronto taking that deal, they'd want something established coming back for Schenn.

Nashville will do Blum for Hemsky, can't see them tossing in their 1st as well.

Same thing for Philly as Toronto, wanting an established piece coming back.

[Johnny Bravo]

Only possibility is Hemsky for Blum and maybe a 2nd. the leafs and flyers wont bite.

[Petro Points]

Originally Posted by moneygoalie31

TO Toronto: PRV and Eager To EDM: Luke Schenn
TO Nashville:Hemsky TO EDM: Ellis or Blum OR 1st
TO Philly: N/A

Mabey way off but I think the value is there in all deals.

Fixed.

[Toydarian]

Originally Posted by Kenny Jonsson

....Same thing for Philly as Toronto, wanting an established piece coming back.

I'm not disagreeing with you over the deals and whether or not they are fair. But Smid is an established player and has deveped into a great defensive Dman which is something hard to quantify without physically watching him. Once again, not saying he could garner B.Schenn in a trade (nor should the Oil trade him), but Smid doesn't get a lot of recognition (which is understandable).

[MessierII]

2nd deal Nashville would never do 3rd deal Edmonton would never do.

[Marlo Stanfield]

Originally Posted by Toydarian

I'm not disagreeing with you over the deals and whether or not they are fair. But Smid is an established player and has deveped into a great defensive Dman which is something hard to quantify without physically watching him. Once again, not saying he could garner B.Schenn in a trade (nor should the Oil trade him), but Smid doesn't get a lot of recognition (which is understandable).

No I understand. Smid is a good stay at home defenseman. But I think what they Flyers are trading (Schenn) they're going to want a chip of equal value back and I personally don't think Smid and Brayden are on equal pegging in terms of value.

[Perro]

Originally Posted by moneygoalie31

TO Toronto: PRV and ANH 2nd To EDM: Luke Schenn
TO Nashville:Hemsky TO EDM: Ellis or Blum and 1st
TO Philly: Smid and Edm 2nd to EDM: Brayden Schenn

Mabey way off but I think the value is there in all deals.

I think the first is a possible off season move as TO needs to gear up this year. PRV is not developed enough to help them get into the playoffs.
I do not not think Hemsky is worth Ellis straight up. Maybe Blum and a 2nd but Nasville fans will likely turn that down to.
Although Philly needs defensive help for Shenn they would want a way better defensman than Smid.