Scott and Rupp are undeniably 1 and 2 in that order. Prust and Bickel are close, but I'd lean towards Prust. After those two I'd put Boyle in there due to his size, followed by Dubinsky, Girardi and Callahan.
Originally Posted by BlueshirtBlitz
Newbury is really good at fighting. He's just not a very good hockey player.
Newbury isn't a very good fighter, especially for someone who drops the gloves fairly regularly.
I completely forgot Danny G could fight. Ever since he became so important to the team, he's done his best to stay out of the box.
Yeah, you can add Cally to the list of fighters. He usually chimes in with 1 or 2 a year. He stepped in after a cheap shot on Dubi this year, i remember him tuning up Mike Comrie, and had a good bout with Cooke after a cheap shot years ago.
I think Rupp takes Bickel and Scott murders them both. Pruster should stay away from all three. But who am I kidding. He wouldn't.
absolutely all of this. Prusty's good when he fights guys he can physically handle. when he tried to fight Lucic, i couldn't believe it. Looch has like 5 inches on the guy. but that's just how Prust is. Rupper would have been a better match. he's my pick, btw. Rupper. Then Scott, Prusty and Bickel, i guess, but every time i've seen Bickel fight, he hasn't really done much. getting your ass kicked by Micheal Haley twice must have sucked...especially considering the height difference.