HHOFers w/o high-end NHL hardware

[RECsGuy*]

Which of its members is without at least one of...

Stanley Cup
Art Ross
Hart
Pearson
Norris
Vezina
Smythe

...and how would you rank them?

I did not include the Adams as I think coaches go in as builders (I could be wrong), and this question only concerns playing careers.

Of those I can think of off the top of my head, I've got, in order...

Stastny
Park
Perreault
Hawerchuk
Lafontaine
Sittler
Neely
M.Howe
Salming
Goulet
Federko
Ciccarelli
Gartner

Any others?

BTW, don't incl. members who were enshrined based on achievements accomplished outside the NHL (Tretiak, Kharlamov).

[reckoning]

Originally Posted by RECsGuy

Of those I can think of off the top of my head, I've got, in order...

Stastny
Park
Perreault
Hawerchuk
Lafontaine
Neely
M.Howe
Federko
Ciccarelli
Gartner

Any others?

Salming
Sittler
Goulet
Gilbert

That's just the expansion era, there were several others from the O6 and early eras.

[pnep]

Park Brad
Ullman Norm
Bentley Doug
Gadsby Bill
Perreault Gil
Ratelle Jean
Hawerchuk Dale
Goulet Michel
Quackenbush Bill
Howe Mark
Salming Borje
Stastny Peter
Gilbert Rod
Sittler Darryl
Lafontaine Pat
Neely Cam
Gartner Mike
Mosienko Bill
Federko Bernie
Boivin Leo
Laprade Edgar
Green Wilf Shorty

[pappyline]

Originally Posted by pnep

Park Brad
Ullman Norm
Bentley Doug
Gadsby Bill
Perreault Gil
Ratelle Jean
Hawerchuk Dale
Goulet Michel
Quackenbush Bill
Howe Mark
Salming Borje
Stastny Peter
Gilbert Rod
Sittler Darryl
Lafontaine Pat
Neely Cam
Gartner Mike
Mosienko Bill
Federko Bernie
Boivin Leo
Laprade Edgar
Green Wilf Shorty

doug bentley probably doesn't belong on this list since he won a scoring title even though it was before the art ross existed.

[Hawkey Town 18]

Originally Posted by pappyline

doug bentley probably doesn't belong on this list since he won a scoring title even though it was before the art ross existed.

Same could be said for Quackenbush, he finished 1st in AS voting twice, meaning he was highly likely to have won at least one Norris had it existed, and probably two.

[vecens24]

Also, had Hart Trophy voting been done the way it is today in 1964-65 as opposed to voting midway through the season then again at the end, it's highly likely Norm Ullman would have won. He had nearly three times as many end of season votes as the next closest, which was Howe.

[reckoning]

Originally Posted by pnep

Park Brad
Ullman Norm
Bentley Doug
Gadsby Bill
Perreault Gil
Ratelle Jean
Hawerchuk Dale
Goulet Michel
Quackenbush Bill
Howe Mark
Salming Borje
Stastny Peter
Gilbert Rod
Sittler Darryl
Lafontaine Pat
Neely Cam
Gartner Mike
Mosienko Bill
Federko Bernie
Boivin Leo
Laprade Edgar
Green Wilf Shorty

Ratelle won the Pearson in 1972.

[Hobnobs]

Perrault, Sittler and Salming are the best imo.

[Hawkey Town 18]

Originally Posted by Hobnobs

Perrault, Sittler and Salming are the best imo.

You probably forgot him, but Park is the clear #1 IMO

[Hobnobs]

Originally Posted by Hawkey Town 18

You probably forgot him, but Park is the clear #1 IMO

Sorry, should have named him too.

[ginopuck]

Originally Posted by vecens24

Also, had Hart Trophy voting been done the way it is today in 1964-65 as opposed to voting midway through the season then again at the end, it's highly likely Norm Ullman would have won. He had nearly three times as many end of season votes as the next closest, which was Howe.

Norm Ullman should have won it that season. He had 42 goals and 83 points while Bobby Hull had 39 goals and 71 points.