Speculation: Grigorenko to Edmonton. Is that even fair?

[Atas2000]

Originally Posted by nafrelio

Not to be too picky, but Eberle was taken 22nd in his draft year. They've only had 2 top picks in a row, although Gagner was 6th and Paajarvi was 10th.

I know, I know. It's just how good Eberle is. and they still can't win a playoff spot.

[SB164]

Originally Posted by God

I heard Grigorenko is actually 21 years old. Any truth to that rumor?

Yeah, tt's the Chinese Olympics gymnastics team controversy all over again.

[I am the Liquor]

Originally Posted by Boco

Oilers only have 1 line that can score and if they're shutdown, then we're screwed. We need Grigorenko.

The Oilers leading scorer on defense is Jeff Petry. He had 25pts this year. It only gets worse from there.

[jebs]

A little premature, lottery still coming up. I dont know about Grig so much anyways, this would be the first time I wouldnt be against trading down a few spots.

[oilchamp99]

How many threads are going to be made about this. Every season is independent, the system is fine and the fairest way. This is how parity is achieved. Pure ignorance if people can't see this.

[I am the Liquor]

Watching Oiler hockey games, over and over again, is not fair.

[YakuBOT]

Originally Posted by I am the Liquor

The Oilers leading scorer on defense is Jeff Petry. He had 25pts this year. It only gets worse from there.

True but watching a whole line become ineffective because the center can't do anything is too painful.

[Kloparren]

Originally Posted by CupofOil

Dubnyk has been terrific in 2012, Roy has had a very good year in the ECHL and Bunz is one of the best goalies in the WHL.
They seem ok in goal.

No he hasn't, you guys have low standards lol. And I suppose Hemsky's been his old 05-06 self as well?

[Inub0i]

Either they...
Get Grigorenko
Not fair

OR

get Murray or Dumba
Not fair

Wow, **** you too life.

[hototogisu]

I don't understand how it's unfair. Sometimes HF forgets that there's a step or two in between "accumulate high draft picks" and "win Stanley Cup".

But watching the Oilers' defense again tonight, it's mind-boggling that so many fans want to go with another forward.

[Zaide]

If I were Edmonton, I'd probably trade down a few spots where Dumba/Murray would still be avalaible to acquire other picks (probably in the 2nd round). I could see Toronto being interested a lot in Grigorenko, same with the Habs. (Assuming the drafting order stays the same)

[pocketful]

Originally Posted by I am the Liquor

The Oilers leading scorer on defense is Jeff Petry. He had 25pts this year. It only gets worse from there.

Not going to deny that Edmonton needs a D that will contribute offensively. Edmonton has quite a few holes to fill yet before they become cup contenders. Goalie: The Dubnyk of late may yet be a reliable starting goalie. Roy and Bunz are having good seasons. Defence: pool prospect pretty deep that just needs time to mature. Forward: 2C. Grigorenko could be that 2C.

[5RingsAndABeer]

Originally Posted by Braden Carlzner

Actually, no.

2011: Adam Larsson, 4th Overall. ----> Straight to the NHL.
2009: Victor Hedman, 2nd Overall. ----> Straight to the NHL.
2008: Drew Doughty, 2nd Overall. ----> Straight to the NHL.

Well 2+ years away from being useful in the NHL (i.e. good enough to improve our team).

[Slicknitty]

thread needs more tambellini troll face

[ZugNugget]

Originally Posted by 5RingsAndABeer

Well 2+ years away from being useful in the NHL (i.e. good enough to improve our team).

That could be a good thing in the long-run.

Drafting in the Top 5 next year, the Oilers could grab MacKinnon, Shinkaruk, Monahan, Barkov, Lazar, or anyone else that starts to look like they could be a #1C.

[Ignoramus*]

Originally Posted by Ashasx

A defense you could cut with a dull, plastic knife.

Sure, if they want to spend $28M on 4 forwards, go ahead.

lol worthy if they draft another forward.

Yeah, it's not like blue chip forwards in their early 20s would be worth anything in trade value or anything.

[KEEROLE Vatanen]

Originally Posted by Eternal Leaf

Hall, Nuge, Eberle, Grigerenko.

That's just filthy.

So is that group of d they have

[OilerGoalie4Vez]

Well if the Oilers can snag Jesse Schultz on June 1 then they probably look to take a forward with there pick. Since they need help down the middle with size Grigorenko would be ideal.

There not to far off from having Klefbom, Mancarin, Gernat, Musil fighting for spots.

[Ashasx]

Originally Posted by Ignoramus

Yeah, it's not like blue chip forwards in their early 20s would be worth anything in trade value or anything.

Then they should be looking to trade this pick.

And if were an Oilers fan, I'd be hoping Tambellini would be looking at that as option number one.

[boredmale]

Originally Posted by Ashasx

Then they should be looking to trade this pick.

And if were an Oilers fan, I'd be hoping Tambellini would be looking at that as option number one.

It's hard to find a trading partner for that pick. basically you have to look for top line players who might be available at the draft and the only guy I can think of currently would be Rick Nash

[Yossarian54]

Originally Posted by hototogisu

I don't understand how it's unfair. Sometimes HF forgets that there's a step or two in between "accumulate high draft picks" and "win Stanley Cup".

But watching the Oilers' defense again tonight, it's mind-boggling that so many fans want to go with another forward.

Word. They still have a way to go from 29th.

[Crusty Quinn]

1. Draft Grigorenko.
2. Play him alongside other talented kids.
3. Grigorenko acquires Calder.
4. Trade Grigorenko for young established d-man.
5. Dynasty

[OilerTyler]

Originally Posted by ZugNugget

That could be a good thing in the long-run.

Drafting in the Top 5 next year, the Oilers could grab MacKinnon, Shinkaruk, Monahan, Barkov, Lazar, or anyone else that starts to look like they could be a #1C.

We can't have that mentality forever. Next year is the year to get out of the lottery.

[YakuBOT]

Originally Posted by Ashasx

Then they should be looking to trade this pick.

And if were an Oilers fan, I'd be hoping Tambellini would be looking at that as option number one.

You don't trade picks when you're the 29th place team and rebuilding.

[clefty]

Unfair why? Because your team isn't getting him?