I'll leave the statistical comparisons to others.
A guy I've worked with over the years caddied for Elmer Lach years ago and said you could never meet a finer gentlman. I brought my father [ he can't get out on his own these days] to see a 9 year old friend of the family play hockey. The old man told the kid that he reminded him of a young Elmer Lach, which I found particularly funny because Mr. Lach retired approx. 41 years before the young man was born.
A very overlooked hockey player. Center of one of the most dangerous line of all-time, Lach retired as the all-time NHL leader in point. The HHOF panel of expert projected him to win the Conn Smythe in 1946 where he scored the winning goal in OT. Unfortunately in played in the shadow of the Rocket.
A wonderful man to chat with. Had the pleasure of an extended conversation with him a few years ago. Great story teller, sharp memory of events over a half-century ago and a very clear in his opinions on the game as it is played today.
One of the toughest guys in the league in his day and a masterful playmaker. Probably overlooked because he came along after the heyday of Lalonde, Morenz and Joliat but had retired before the "Drive to Five" years.
One of my favorite hockey photographs is the one taken moments after Lach scored the Cup-winner in 1953. It shows he and Richard in a high-impact embrace (Lach broke his nose on Richard's forehead) in the center of the frame but off to one side sits a visibly very dejected Milt Schmidt, who's giveaway resulted in the goal.