Remember when everybody outside of Detroit said you could never win a cup with Osgood as your goalie?
You just made a comment of similar value.
No, I don't believe he has. Osgood was a great career backup goalie, who was a little long in the tooth. He did, however have a unbelievable team in front of him. So comparing a young prospect who will fill an glaring need, to a career back-up who played solidly, not world class but solidly is not a fair comparison.