I'd rather have two solid d-men than one great one. Both Weber and Suitor have tremendus upside. The've only begain to show what the can do! Two TOp d-men of the future IMO!
I'd rather have one great one than two solid ones. But I don't think Suter and Weber are going to be just solid. They are key contributors to one of the best teams in hockey at the ages of 21 and 20 respectively.