I'd be ecstastic if one of those guys you mentioned was brought on.
But all the names we hear about are Hartley, Crawford and Therrien.
Blech. All I have to say to that.
Agreed that Guy isn't leaving Tampa. I was just stating him...
You talk as if any of those guys were old timer coaches, which they really aren't. I think that it's a mistake to underestimate the experience of a coach, these guys are proven winners and they have done so at multiple levels.
I would say bleh if you named me a guy like Mike Keenan as an example.
I really like Mellanby and his character, this is a positive addition no matter what. Gainey, lol... good riddance
This is a good addition...as for your Gainey remark are you saying Gainey had no character??? One of the most respected men in the game, and you say good riddance...the guy did an awful lot for the Habs franchise, and deserves a little more respect, wouldn't you think?
Anyhow, Bergevin is assembling a great team, and this is all very positive news...
I love this, this is shaping up to be a turning point in the Montreal Canadiens history, they are actually going out and hiring knowledgable/English speaking professionals to get the job done! I think that the next move will be to hire the best coaching staff to coach and develop our team for years.
Cannot wait for the draft in June!
Bergevin is as québécois as they come. Mellanby and Carrière were born in Montreal and are billingual.
I don't care that much about the "french factor". I just tought that what you said sounded really wrong.
A few friends and I met Mellanby about 4 years ago at Wayne Gretzkys restaurant during the summer. He was a super nice guy very open and well spoken. We joined him at the bar for a drink and he bought us a round as well. He also had a great sense of humor and laughed a lot during our conversation. He was meeting another former player I believe Paul Laus? for some drinks and then they were going down to see a Blue Jays game. Seemed like a very happy and positive person should be a great addition to the team! Welcome Scott!
Bob Hartley is said to rely heavily on veterans but shows little patience with young players.
He relied heavily on young Alex Tanguay during the Cup run and game 7 against the Devils back in 2001. Don't really believe that and every coach in every sport always will rely a little more on veterans
This is exactly what the Habs have needed to do. Expand on their management staff. If you observe the Wings management team, there are assistants and multiple positions everywhere. Good on Molson on finding a guy who wants to work with others and also provide Bergevin with the resources.
Independently of my opinion of Harley, an honest question: is there a coach in the NHL who does NOT suffer from that criticism?
Seems to be the first complaint to come out against just about any coach.
Every single coach in the nhl does, experienced guys do things the right way because they have been around a long time, younger players make mistakes cause they have not been around a long time it's as simple as it gets. People who say otherwise are just stupid
I don't know about you guys but when I hear "Director of Player Personnel"...I don't think of player developement. I think of someone that works with the players with any issues, is a liason between coaches, managers and players and someone that would also help with off-ice issues, motivating guys etc...I could be wrong.
Good gawd! People are actually critiquing Lindy Ruff for riding Miller down the stretch? Now I've seen it all !
Originally Posted by Pernell Karl
Ryan Miller after the allstar break:
19-6-5 2.08 GAA .931 Save %
What was Ruff thinking playing him that much down the stretch...
No one is critiquing the fact that Ruff started Miller, 1 poster said that Ruff was one that didn't rely much on veterans and the Miller starting 34 of the last 36 games was brought up since Enroth wasn't playing bad and could have been used more. Miller is the veteran and #1 and that's why he plays. But he trusted his veteran and that was the point read more people
- Scott grew up idolizing the Canadiens and Guy Lafleur, so it means a lot for him to be part of the organization.
- He's friends with Don Cherry, Don has done a lot for him and his family.
- Known for the rats in Florida, really proud of where the franchise is now. Hasn't done a lot of interviews without bringing it up.
- Scored first franchise goal in Atlanta.
- Worked for Mike Gillis in Vancouver, did some scouting and then went behind the bench with St-Louis.
- He's not afraid of saying: He's played 21 years in the NHL, he doesn't care if you are a broadcaster, commentator or owner, the greatest job for him is being a player. He can't be a player forever, and so he decided to stay in the NHL and worked in Vancouver. He liked having a say in what players could do and who to sign during free agency. When the opportunity to coach came on, he felt it was an opportunity he couldn't pass by. He has learned a lot from it, it's going to help him, but he knows his passion is in building a team and wants to make that his job. He loves scouting and evaluating.
- When Marc Bergevin got nominated, he thought of joining him. They played together in St-Louis, and they've talked in the past, Marc offered him a job with the Blackhawks but he wasn't ready, he had just retired.
- Marc called Doug Armstrong last week and asked to speak with Scott, and it was a short conversation, Mellanby wanted to work for the Habs.
- Left the Blues, and all the players were very supportive of him. He says he can't have that same relationship as he had as a coach, there are limitations on the relationship. It'll be more difficult for him at this point, as Player Personnel, there's more travelling and less time to be close to players. That's why it's important to put togehter a good coaching staff because it's their job to look after the players on a day-to-day basis.
- His relationship is with Marc. He has crossed paths with Dudley, they both scouted so they had opportunities to meet. Doesn't know him really that well. Rick is a guy he got to know through Marc, when he was in Chicago. Says Dudley is a class act with a great reputation in the league, the hardest working guy in hockey and has a great track record for evaluating player.
- The Canadiens over the last couple of years: "Like a lot of team, this league is a fine line". The right coaching staff makes the difference. 10% and 15% is the difference between 98 points and 88 points. It's our job to find the right players with the right attitude and behaviour to make that 10-15%, make the players around them better. He has coach in the Western conference last year so he doesn't know the East that well, he says tehre are a lot of good assets here (Montreal), and you have to build around that.
- Really excited at the opportunity to work with Marc, Rick and Larry.
-Decided to leave coaching to become management because: He saw Kirk Muller, and saw how much he loves coaching, and as an ex-player, he felt guilty because he was supposed to love it but he wasn't that passionate about coaching. He didn't mind it, but he cares so much about winning and losing (so do those guys (coaches)), but for him at times it was more frustrating and so he felt like he wanted to get on the ice and start playing... so for him it felt too close to being a player. He felt a part of the room and he realized he's a coaich and so he's not part of the room. As a management person, he gets to take a step back and isn't as emotionally invested in it. When he will be scouting, he can scout without feeling connected to the team. He felt he was too close in his time as a coach.
- Had a scrap with Chris Nilan. Knuckles was very excited when Scott Mellanby was linked to the Canadiens.
Last edited by Jack Bourdain: 05-28-2012 at 03:55 PM.