Value of: Khabibulin/Gagner/Whitney/Hemsky

[oilersfan11]

What can the Oilers get for these 4?

[lakai17]

Hemsky stays.

[jumptheshark]

this will no end well for oiler fans

Nothing for habby
Not what Gagner is worth
Whitney may never be 100% again and that second rounder the Ducks got for Lubor at the draft could look good to the oilers shortly
Hemsky--whether oiler fans like it or not--an injury prone winger wont get you much

[Henrik To Daniel]

Gagner for a 2nd

[Dr Swag]

Is Khabibulin good enough to be the Leaf's #1 and backstop them to the playoffs?

[lebdafor norris]

Whitney- 3rd or 4th round pick (look what vishnovsky got and his the better player)
Gagner- mid to late 1st
Hemsky- 2nd rounder
Khabibulan- late pick

[Falco Lombardi]

I'd give a 2nd for Gagner maybe, but he really doesn't fit our system.

No interest in the rest

[oilersfan11]

Originally Posted by DogEatDog

this will no end well for oiler fans

Nothing for habby
Not what Gagner is worth
Whitney may never be 100% again and that second rounder the Ducks got for Lubor at the draft could look good to the oilers shortly
Hemsky--whether oiler fans like it or not--an injury prone winger wont get you much

Not even a 7th rounder?

[Fastasaurus]

Thomas and a 7th for khabibulin

[Uncle Howie]

Khabby- 2nd rounder at best, more likely 3rd
Gagner- mid to late 1st rounder
Whitney- 2nd rounder or B level prospect
Hemsky- 2nd rounder (has averaged 42 games over the last 3 years, hurts his value tremendously).. perhaps if he plays 70 games or more this year, I could see him going for a late first in 2013\2014

[dubplatepressure]

Lombard/Armstrong/Connolly/Komisarek?

[oilersfan11]

Originally Posted by Uncle Howie

Khabby- 2nd rounder at best, more likely 3rd
Gagner- mid to late 1st rounder
Whitney- 2nd rounder or B level prospect
Hemsky- 2nd rounder (has averaged 42 games over the last 3 years, hurts his value tremendously).. perhaps if he plays 70 games or more this year, I could see him going for a late first in 2013\2014

Deal on all of them!

[King Woodballs]

I wouldnt want any of them on my team

[Liferleafer]

Originally Posted by Dr Swag

Is Khabibulin good enough to be the Leaf's #1 and backstop them to the playoffs?

Been thinking about this myself.

[Soundwave]

Oilers are better off keeping all four and simply just signing a couple of players like a Bryan Allen for the D and a Jordin Tootoo to mix things up.

Whitney is cap room in the future, Hemsky is short term too, so he's also cap room in the future. Khabby is up after this season too and will be fine the experienced back up role and can help out Yakupov as well.

[TorontoTrades]

if Luongo deal falls through the Leafs may be interested but at a very low price.

[Liferleafer]

Originally Posted by TorontoTrades

if Luongo deal falls through the Leafs may be interested but at a very low price.

How much for Gagner and Habby?

Franson and a 2nd or 3rd?

[TorontoTrades]

Originally Posted by Liferleafer

How much for Gagner and Habby?

Franson and a 2nd or 3rd?

really see no use for Gagner in Toronto.

Grabovski is our 2C and we have a plethora of guys that can play 3C

even if the thinking was to put him at 1C I don't see him being an improvement over Bozak.

I'd give no more than a 3rd for Habby.

[Liferleafer]

Originally Posted by TorontoTrades

really see no use for Gagner in Toronto.

Grabovski is our 2C and we have a plethora of guys that can play 3C

even if the thinking was to put him at 1C I don't see him being an improvement over Bozak.

I'd give no more than a 3rd for Habby.

I still think Gagner is gonna get much better. Also love his speed...just me though.

[TorontoTrades]

Originally Posted by Liferleafer

I still think Gagner is gonna get much better. Also love his speed...just me though.

to me he brings everything we have in Bozak.

Bozie had a great year and would like to see if he can build on it before shipping a 2nd for a similar talent.

[Oilfan2]

Originally Posted by oilersfan11

Deal on all of them!

How about you just change your user name and quit posting about the Oilers, especially on the main boards... embarrassing....

[oilerbear]

Originally Posted by oilersfan11

What can the Oilers get for these 4?

Gagner first 5 seasons;
366GM 77G 143A 220P

J. staal's first 5 seasons
369GM 95G 103A 198P

Someone will say Gagner is worth a 2nd.

[oilersfan11]

Originally Posted by oilfan22

How about you just change your user name and quit posting about the Oilers, especially on the main boards... embarrassing....

Sorry bud but It's freedom of speech.


I will speak what I think.

[oilersfan11]

Originally Posted by oilerbear

Gagner first 5 seasons;
366GM 77G 143A 220P

J. staal's first 5 seasons
369GM 95G 103A 198P

Someone will say Gagner is worth a 2nd.

Very bad comparison,Gagner does nothing else but score.

[ChillyPalmer]

I'd give up a mid to late 1st for Gagner, easy.