Horcoff is playing almost as bad as Smyth. Horcoff needs press box he is making too many mistakes and really frustrating everyone. He had a lucky string of games and now people think he is supposed to be better than he is.
I'd prefer to get Smyth to the wing. He's not any better than Horcoff at center. I'd go with:
Torres - York - Dvorak
Smyth - Oates - Hemsky
Moreau - Stoll - Pisani
Laraque - Horcoff - Isbister
I don't like having Izzy on the 4th line, but those 3 have been successfull before. And we should have two legitimate top lines and a good checking line.
The point of the thread is getting Horcoff out though, And with your lines, Chimera sits again? Of course, with MAcT its always a possibility, i just hope Horcoff won't be playing. Oiler players always seem to do better after they sit for a game, case and point Isbister (for a while) and Hemsky.