Start/Sit Week 5

[Big Poppa Puck]

Here's the week 5 thread.

My dilemmas:

Torrey Smith or Antonio Brown?

Ryan Mathews or Alfred Morris?

and in my TD only league:
Brian Hartline or Andre Roberts?

Isaac Redman or Shane Vereen? (digging real deep here, Murray on BYE and nothing on the FA list)

[Alivesi]

NFL.com Standard

Darren Sproles Vs Rashard Mendenhall Vs Ben Tate ? Threw in Tate just cause.

[GrigsAndGirgs]

Originally Posted by iRep TheWingedWheel

Here's the week 5 thread.

My dilemmas:

Torrey Smith or Antonio Brown?

Ryan Mathews or Alfred Morris?

and in my TD only league:
Brian Hartline or Andre Roberts?

Isaac Redman or Shane Vereen? (digging real deep here, Murray on BYE and nothing on the FA list)

IMO: Smith, Morris, Roberts, and Redman.

Vereen is a non-starter given Ridley and Bolden there. Redman should get some touches, though who knows how many.

Don't count on Tannehill throwing TDs. Roberts though has found the end zone this season.

Torrey Smith seems like a good bet against the Chiefs. I'm taking Morris because he seems to be getting a consistent workload.

===============

Here's my conundrum:

Giants D vs Browns, or Packers D @ Colts

Both look like great matchups, so I don't know which way to lean.

[ShadowDuck]

My RBs are such a mess.

Chris Johnson
BJGE
DeAngelo Williams
Ben Tate
Jackie Battle

I need 2 and I've picked wrong literally every week. Luckily my WRs are stacked.

[TLinden16]

Dalton vs Miami
Newton vs Seattle (I benched him last week and I'm skeptical he'll put up some shaky stats if I go back to him )

Hartline @ CAR
Andre Roberts vs STL

Thoughts?

[TorontoAvalanche]

Pick 4

Ben Tate
CJ Spiller
Fred Jackson
BenJarvus Green-Ellis
Rashard Mendenhall

I really don't know who to choose. Mendenhall is back but he will surely be rusty, Spiller and Jackson are up against a tough 49ers defense and Tate has just been terrible so far.

Help is appreciated, thanks in advance

[IU Hawks fan]

Originally Posted by GrigsAndGirgs

Here's my conundrum:

Giants D vs Browns, or Packers D @ Colts

Both look like great matchups, so I don't know which way to lean.

Giants. Weeden's thrown 7 picks, Giants should feast on that.

DSTs and kickers are a lottery, though, so I could be completely wrong. Good problem to have having 2 good ones like that to work with.

[IU Hawks fan]

Originally Posted by TorontoAvalanche

Pick 4

Ben Tate
CJ Spiller
Fred Jackson
BenJarvus Green-Ellis
Rashard Mendenhall

I really don't know who to choose. Mendenhall is back but he will surely be rusty, Spiller and Jackson are up against a tough 49ers defense and Tate has just been terrible so far.

Help is appreciated, thanks in advance

Law Firm is a given, having not mentioned it I imagine you know that already.

Of the other 3, I guess I have to go Mendenhall, Jackson, and Spiller. Tate may not play.

Anything good on the wire? Ryan Williams? Powell?

Hell, could even grab Justin Forsett at game time if Tate is announced out.

[Diskothek]

Bold is what I've got right now...

Pick 1 of 3

Boldin @ KC
Hawkins vs MIA
Wayne @ GB

Pick 2 of 4

Charles vs BAL
Lawfirm vs MIA
Spiller @ SF
Sproles vs SD

[Fire Lindy]

I have a TE dilemma, Finley @ IND or Olson vs SEA. Finley continues to drop passes and just suck, awhile Olson and Newton seem to have some good chemistry going on. Finley has the better matchup here though.

[Bob Richards]

DeSean Jackson or Dwayne Bowe?

[MJG]

Originally Posted by Bob Richards

DeSean Jackson or Dwayne Bowe?

Bowe

[MJG]

Finley or Rudolph ?

[TML g u n n e R s*]

roberts vs rams

or

steve smith vs that nasty secondary in Seattle

[tbcwpg]

In a deep league with very little left on the wire, in a bye so my WR2 spot is open.

Donnie Avery vs GB or Andrew Hawkins vs MIA? I also have a claim on Hixon but I'm last on the wire order so if I get him I'll be lucky. If I do, is he worth starting over the other two?

[devils4cup]

Tebow or Empty Slot?

[GrigsAndGirgs]

Originally Posted by tbcwpg

In a deep league with very little left on the wire, in a bye so my WR2 spot is open.

Donnie Avery vs GB or Andrew Hawkins vs MIA? I also have a claim on Hixon but I'm last on the wire order so if I get him I'll be lucky. If I do, is he worth starting over the other two?

Hawkins. He has the big play ability.

[MurrayBannerman]

Originally Posted by MJG

Finley or Rudolph ?

Rudolph

[Kronwalled55]

Need a flex this week

Manningham vs. BUF
Bess @ CIN
Little @ NYG
S. Rice @ CAR

I currently only own Little and Rice, but the top 2 seem more favorable and are FAs.

[Fighter]

Originally Posted by iRep TheWingedWheel

Here's the week 5 thread.

My dilemmas:

Torrey Smith or Antonio Brown?

Ryan Mathews or Alfred Morris?

and in my TD only league:
Brian Hartline or Andre Roberts?

Isaac Redman or Shane Vereen? (digging real deep here, Murray on BYE and nothing on the FA list)

I have both and starting both but Antonio seems more consistent.
Morris
Roberts
Redman

Originally Posted by Alivesi

NFL.com Standard

Darren Sproles Vs Rashard Mendenhall Vs Ben Tate ? Threw in Tate just cause.

Sproles easily

[Everlong]

Need 2 of 3 WR:

Mike Wallace vPHI
Erik Decker @NE
Malcom Floyd @NO

[tbcwpg]

Also a D/ST question, Vikings against TEN or Pittsburgh against PHI? Good matchup for Minnesota, but the Steelers will be getting guys back on D that should help them, and Vick is having some turnover trouble.

[DEVILS ALL THE WAY]

1) Vick or Flacco
and
2) Steelers or Falcons

Thanks

[sa cyred]

Just got one.

Jermichael Finley or Scott Chandler?

Finley really hasnt done much while Chandler has been up and down.

[tv14]

Pick 3 (2WR spots and 1 flex):

Steve Smith vs SEA
Marques Colston vs SD
Malcolm Floyd @ NWO
DeSean Jackson @ PIT
Andre Roberts @ STL

They have all produced very similar through the first 4 weeks, so it makes it difficult to choose on a week-to-week basis! Also do you guys think this is too much depth at WR for only have 2 WR spots and one flex (WR/RB)?