Line Brawl Lineups

[TieClark]

Originally Posted by KingForsberg

Wayne Simmonds - Tom Sestito - Zac Rinaldo

Luke Schenn - Braydon Coburn

If Shelley is still around then maybe him over Rinaldo or Sestito. Another possibility is Grossman on defense.

Schenn needs fighting lessons. He is insanely strong but isn't a very good fighter

[MonsterSurge]

Originally Posted by TieClark

Schenn needs fighting lessons. He is insanely strong but isn't a very good fighter

Schenn is actually a decent fighter. He's a lefty, too.

[TieClark]

Originally Posted by MonsterSurge

Schenn is actually a decent fighter. He's a lefty, too.

Not really. He loses to anyone who fights semi-frequently.

[Kevin27NYI]

Boulton-Cizikas-Martin
Hamonic-Carkner

[hlaverty06]

Barch-Clarkson-Janssen
Salvador-not sure

[MonsterSurge]

Originally Posted by Kevin27NYI

Boulton-Cizikas-Martin
Hamonic-Carkner

No Gallant?

[newfy]

I wouldnt mind seeing some more actual potential line ups instead of guys who are AHL goons that are just in the system

Detroit would be:

Bertuzzi - Abdelkader - Tootoo

Smith - Ericcson

While not the toughest lineup in the thread they could handle themselves and would have a high chance of being on the ice because theyll all play over 10 mins a game

[Tkachuk4MVP]

Clowe-Thornton-Burish

Murray-Burns


I'd be confident putting that group up against just about anybody.

[MonsterSurge]

Originally Posted by Tkachuk4MVP

Clowe-Thornton-Burish

Murray-Burns


I'd be confident putting that group up against just about anybody.

You're missing a bunch of willing AHL guys like Curt Gogol and such.

[bud12]

Originally Posted by Tkachuk4MVP

Clowe-Thornton-Burish

Murray-Burns


I'd be confident putting that group up against just about anybody.

Clowe is the only one who is a good fighter!

[MichiganWolverines]

Originally Posted by Tkachuk4MVP

Clowe-Thornton-Burish

Murray-Burns


I'd be confident putting that group up against just about anybody.

These are match-ups I made if there was a line brawl off of the faceoff:

Keven Veilleux vs. Joe Thornton Draw/Narrow win Veilleux.
Steve MacIntyre vs. Adam Burish
Zach Sill vs. Ryane Clowe Draw/Narrow win Clowe.
Robert Bortuzzo vs. Brent Burns Narrow win Bortuzzo.
Deryk Engelland vs. Douglas Murray Clear win Engelland.

[MonsterSurge]

Originally Posted by MichiganWolverines

These are match-ups I made if there was a line brawl off of the faceoff:

Keven Veilleux vs. Joe Thornton Draw/Narrow win Veilleux.
Steve MacIntyre vs. Adam Burish
Zach Sill vs. Ryane Clowe Draw/Narrow win Clowe.
Robert Bortuzzo vs. Brent Burns Narrow win Bortuzzo.
Deryk Engelland vs. Douglas Murray Clear win Engelland.

Sill could beat Clowe...

[MonsterSurge]

MacIntyre - Veilleux - Sill

Engelland - Merth

Killeen


I made it better!

[MichiganWolverines]

Originally Posted by MonsterSurge

MacIntyre - Veilleux - Sill

Engelland - Merth

Killeen


I made it better!

Too bad we got rid of Boris Valabik. If he stayed healthy he probably would have been re-signed. Brent Johnson would be great for the brawl too if he was still on the pens.

[BlueDream]

Yeah too bad your Penguins lineups are completely unrealistic. At least the Sharks are using players who will actually be on the team.

He could bring up fighters from the minors too...

[MonsterSurge]

Originally Posted by BlueDream

Yeah too bad your Penguins lineups are completely unrealistic. At least the Sharks are using players who will actually be on the team.

He could bring up fighters from the minors too...

Uh...Veilleux and Sill are guys we have wanted in the NHL for a while. MacIntyre is pretty realistic.

[kirby11]

Kaleta-McCormick-Scott
Regehr-Weber

We have such a weak lineup...

[MonsterSurge]

Originally Posted by kirby11

Kaleta-McCormick-Scott
Regehr-Weber

We have such a weak lineup...

Put Ott on defense or throw in Finley.

[WildcatMapleLeafs28]

Originally Posted by MonsterSurge

Sill could beat Clowe...

As much as I like Sill, Clowe is a beast and playing in the NHL. He'd make short work of Zach.

[Kevin27NYI]

Originally Posted by MonsterSurge

No Gallant?

I don't think he'll see any NHL time.

[nullterm]

Oilers...

Eager-Gagner-Hordichuk
Peckham-Sutton/Teubert

Sad thing is, I'm more confident Gags would drop the mitts than Eager.

[MonsterSurge]

Originally Posted by WildcatMapleLeafs28

As much as I like Sill, Clowe is a beast and playing in the NHL. He'd make short work of Zach.

I doubt it. Sill handled Liambas and Liambas is one of the toughest guys in the ECHL. The league doesn't matter.

[Qward]

2011/12 Sens

Konopka/Smith/Neil
Carkner/Cowen

2012/13 Sens

Greening/Smith/Neil
Methot/Cowen

[newfy]

Originally Posted by MonsterSurge

Uh...Veilleux and Sill are guys we have wanted in the NHL for a while. MacIntyre is pretty realistic.

Youre a guy who posts on the hockey fights board, of course you want those guys in the NHL but that doesnt mean its realistic to have them in a line brawl line up. The chances those guys play 2 games nexy season are slim

Originally Posted by MonsterSurge

I doubt it. Sill handled Liambas and Liambas is one of the toughest guys in the ECHL. The league doesn't matter.

Liambas is 5'9 and while a solid pound for pound guy is nothing to write home about. I agree Sill is a tough guy for sure but Liambas is not a good measuring stick for that

[PJ StockBB]

Bruins:

Lucic-Horton-Thornton

Chara-McQuaid

Rask

unlike some of the AHL scrubs that a few posters are putting in their lineups, Lane MacDermid actually has played a few games in the NHL for the Bruins and has a good shot at being the 13th forward (if there is a season this year) because he can do more than just fight. so if he does make it our lineup could look like...

Lucic-MacDermid-Thornton

Chara-McQuaid

Rask