From the Rangers: McDonagh
In two on two, there can be no better option than Datsyuk. He's a great defender and pick-pocket, phenomenal playmaker and arguably the slickest puck handler in the world. With only two opponents he could dangle his way to the net at will, and if he is impeded, he'll just make a nice dish to his open teammate.
Local: Phil Kessel, easy just get the puck to him and he'll do the rest.
NHL: Maybe an unpopular pick but probably Karlsson, he'd have a field day with all that open ice and even if he isn't elite defensively in the NHL he'd still more than likely have an easy time stripping the puck from the opposition and then skate down the ice leaving them behind. Not only is he extremely fast but he's one of the best in the World at using his speed, especially on defense and once he gets the puck, forget about it.