Going Gardiner. I think his skillset plays more than Della Rovere. I had high hopes for Della Rovere, but my candle is burning pretty low. Lundstrom, Lindbohm, and Tremblay are all right there as well. Hard to get too excited about Europeans, when they are still in Europe.
I'm going with Nigro again. I think that one of Lundström or Tremblay will likely be worth more to The Blues in the long run. But it is way too early to know how a goalie prospect in juniors will end up in the prime of his career. Too many things can happen to derail a good start. The mental game of a goalie is so much more important than with a skater, that even a goalie with top-notch physical prowess, goalie skills and knowledge can have his career fall in the dumper.