Not really a very fair poll. To say Grabovski is better would require some serious homer goggles. And that's not a slight against Grabovski either, he's a solid 2nd line center, just that Plekanec is an excellent 2nd line to fringe 1st line center.
Plekanec but it's closer than people think. Also not so sure why people are saying Plekanec is better offensively, they're pretty much equals in that department. Their points per game the past two seasons have been nearly identical (0.64 and 0.74 for Plekanec, 0.69 and 0.72 for Grabovski). Both guys the past two seasons have been given shutdown duties, obviously Plekanec is the better player defensively overall. Plekanec has the 70 and 69 point seasons but he was not used in the same role he is today in those seasons.