Roster Talk '13 — Canada 3.0

EveryDay · 12-12-2012, 07:25 PM

Who's left?

FLYguy3911 · 12-12-2012, 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheGleninator

True but he has been much more offensive this season and this camp than Dumba so I think Dumba and Wotherspoon are more of the character number 7's and Corrado and Murphy are going to be relied on more for offense just my feeling.

The 7th defenseman is probably an offensive guy like Dumba or Murphy (well Dumba can fill a lot of roles).

Tiranis · 12-12-2012, 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheGleninator

True but he has been much more offensive this season and this camp than Dumba so I think Dumba and Wotherspoon are more of the character number 7's and Corrado and Murphy are going to be relied on more for offense just my feeling.

That doesn't make much sense. Corrado is a defensive guy first despite playing a bit more offensively this season. Scoring 2 goals didn't suddenly change that. Also calling Dumba and Wotherspoon "character" guys ... Corrado is the captain of Sudbury, he's as much a character guy as them.

Snippit · 12-12-2012, 07:26 PM

31 guys on the team.

GOALIES

-Subban - LOCK
-Binnington
-Brossoit
-Paterson

DEFENCE

-Hamilton - LOCK
-Rielly - LOCK
-Harrington - LOCK
-Ouellet - LOCK
-Reinhart
-Corrado
-Sproul
-Dumba
-Wotherspoon
-Murphy

FORWARDS

-RNH - LOCK
-Scheifele - LOCK
-Huberdeau - LOCK
-Mackinnon - LOCK
-Drouin
-Rattie - LOCK
-Camara
-Catenacci
-Danault - LOCK
-Hudon - LOCK
-Jenner - LOCK
-Lipon
-McNeill
-Ritchie
-Shinkaruk
-Wilson
-Strome - LOCK

TheHudlinator · 12-12-2012, 07:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiranis

That doesn't make much sense. Corrado is a defensive guy first despite playing a bit more offensively this season. Also calling Dumba and Wotherspoon "character" guys ... Corrado is a captain of Sudbury, he's as much a character guy as those guys.

I didn't say he didn't have character but if either Dumba or Wotherspoon makes it is going to be based on their character where I believe Corrado has a spot in the top 6.

Paralyzer008 · 12-12-2012, 07:27 PM

My final 8 cuts are:
Jake Paterson
Frank Corrado (Yeah Dumba has been bad but his dynamic style will likely overshadow that to be the No.7 D)
Ryan Sproul
Tyler Wotherspoon
Anthony Camara
Daniel Catenacci
Hunter Shinkaruk
J.C. Lipon (hardest cut for me to make)

SergeConstantin74 · 12-12-2012, 07:27 PM

When did MacKinnon become a lock?

FLYguy3911 · 12-12-2012, 07:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PRNuck

I don't want to get all "Canuck fan" in here, but he's tied for 6th in OHL D-men scoring.

Yeah but he's a defense first guy. Doesn't mean he's a stiff, but you won't see him on the PP in the tourny. Points aren't everything.

Snippit · 12-12-2012, 07:28 PM

Do you really see Mackinnon getting cut?

jfb392 · 12-12-2012, 07:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SergeConstantin74

When did MacKinnon become a lock?

After his first two days of camp.

Mathletic · 12-12-2012, 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snippit

31 guys on the team.

GOALIES

-Subban - LOCK
-Binnington
-Brossoit
-Paterson

DEFENCE

-Hamilton - LOCK
-Rielly - LOCK
-Harrington - LOCK
-Ouellet - LOCK
-Reinhart
-Corrado
-Sproul
-Dumba
-Wotherspoon
-Murphy

FORWARDS

-RNH - LOCK
-Scheifele - LOCK
-Huberdeau - LOCK
-Mackinnon - LOCK
-Drouin
-Rattie - LOCK
-Camara
-Catenacci
-Danault - LOCK
-Hudon - LOCK
-Jenner - LOCK
-Lipon
-McNeill
-Ritchie
-Shinkaruk
-Wilson
-Strome - LOCK

Ritchie is a lock as he did not play today.

Ashasx · 12-12-2012, 07:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SergeConstantin74

When did MacKinnon become a lock?

Nate has arguably been the best player these first 2 days.

Canada has made huge mistakes cutting dynamic, younger talents in favour of older players these last 3 years. They can't screw it up this time.

SergeConstantin74 · 12-12-2012, 07:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Snippit

Do you really see Mackinnon getting cut?

I want him to make the team but I don't think he's a lock.

TC has made pretty dumb decisions not taking many superior 17 yo in the past.

MyNameIsNobody · 12-12-2012, 07:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun Bisson

Rishaug says no more cuts tonight. Pelech, Graovac, Monahan, Pouliot, Beauvillier the cuts tonight.

Bold are cut
Players left:

Jordan*Binnington L 6'2 168 7/11/1993 STL '11 (3, 88)
Laurent*Brossoit L 6'3 200 3/23/1993 CGY '11 (6, 164)
Jake*Paterson L 6'1 183 5/3/1994 DET '12 (3, 80)
Malcolm*Subban L 6'2 200 12/21/1993 BOS '12 (1, 24)

Frank*Corrado R 6'0 190 3/26/1993 VAN '11 (5, 150)
Mathew*Dumba R 6'0 183 7/25/1994 MIN '12 (1, 7)
Dougie*Hamilton * R 6'5 205 6/17/1993 BOS '11 (1, 9)
Scott*Harrington * L 6'2 200 3/10/1993 PIT '11 (2, 54)
Ryan*Murphy R 5'11 176 3/31/1993 CAR '11 (1, 12)
Xavier*Ouellet L 6'1 190 7/29/1993 DET '11 (2, 48)
Adam Pelech L 6'2 210 8/18/1994 NYI '12 (3, 65)
Derrick Pouliot L 6'0 192 1/16/1994 PIT '12 (1, 8)
Griffin*Reinhart L 6'4 202 1/24/1994 NYI '12 (1, 4)
Morgan*Rielly L 6'0 205 3/9/1994 TOR '12 (1, 5)
Ryan*Sproul R 6'4 193 1/13/1993 DET '11 (2, 55)
Tyler*Wotherspoon L 6'1.5 209 3/12/1993 CGY '11 (2, 57)

Francis*Beauvillier L 6'1.5 187 10/22/1993 FLA '12 (6, 174)
Anthony*Camara L 6'1 195 9/4/1993 BOS '11 (3, 81)
Daniel*Catenacci L 5'10 191 3/9/1993 BUF '11 (3, 77)
Phillip*Danault L 6'0 189 2/24/1993 CHI '11 (1, 26)
Jonathan*Drouin L 5'10.5 185 3/28/1995 2013 Dft
Tyler*Graovac L 6'3 203 4/27/1993 MIN '11 (7, 191)
Jonathan*Huberdeau * L 6'1 176 6/4/1993 FLA '11 (1, 3)
Charles*Hudon L 5'11 171 6/24/1994 MTL '12 (5, 122)
Boone*Jenner * L 6'2 205 6/15/1993 CBJ '11 (2, 37)
J.C.*Lipon R 5'11.5 180 7/10/1993 2013 Dft/Rep.
Nathan*MacKinnon R 5'11 179 9/1/1995 2013 Dft
Mark*McNeill R 6'2 210 2/22/1993 CHI ’11 (1, 18)
Sean*Monahan L 6'2 193 10/12/1994 2013 Dft
Ryan*Nugent-Hopkins L 6'0 185 4/12/1993 EDM ’11 (1, 1)
Ty*Rattie R 6'0 176 2/5/1993 STL ’11 (2, 32)
Brett*Ritchie R 6'4 218 7/1/1993 DAL ’11 (2, 44)
Mark*Scheifele * R 6'3 187 3/15/1993 WPG ’11 (1, 7)
Hunter*Shinkaruk L 5'11 175 10/13/1994 2013 Dft
Ryan*Strome * R 6'1 192 7/11/1993 NYI ’11 (1, 5)
Tom Wilson R 6'4 210 03/29/1994

Shaun Bisson · 12-12-2012, 07:31 PM

My final 8 cuts:

Dumba, Wotherspoon, Sproul, McNeill, Camara, Catennaci, Lipon, Subban.

Subban is gonna cause some controversy, but based on play so far this camp, he shouldn't make the team.

TheHudlinator · 12-12-2012, 07:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun Bisson

My final 8 cuts:

Dumba, Wotherspoon, Sproul, McNeill, Camara, Catennaci, Lipon, Subban.

Subban is gonna cause some controversy, but based on play so far this camp, he shouldn't make the team.

Who would be your starter and backup if you want to cut Subban?

Snippit · 12-12-2012, 07:34 PM

My new predictions:

Scheifele-RNH-Rattie - Top scoring line
Huberdeau-Mackinnon-Drouin - Chemistry, elite skill
Ritchie-Strome-Jenner - Niagara chemistry, Jenner+Ritchie bring physicality
Hudon-Danault-McNeill - Checking line
Shinkaruk

Rielly-Hamilton - Top D Pair
Harrington-Ouellet - Shut down
Reinhart - Corrado
Murphy

Subban
Paterson

Atomos2 · 12-12-2012, 07:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Serbian Power

Wow. Dumba was kept yet Pouliot was cut. I don't understand that one bit... but let's see what happens tomorrow. I guess Pouliot fell into the OFD category?

Not surprised. Spott is pretty loyal. Dumba was his captain and top player last year in the U18's so he will give him every opportunity to succeed. Just like he's doing with Murphy

FLYguy3911 · 12-12-2012, 07:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun Bisson

My final 8 cuts:

Dumba, Wotherspoon, Sproul, McNeill, Camara, Catennaci, Lipon, Subban.

Subban is gonna cause some controversy, but based on play so far this camp, he shouldn't make the team.

30 minutes of play overrides the last two years?

EveryDay · 12-12-2012, 07:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun Bisson

My final 8 cuts:

Dumba, Wotherspoon, Sproul, McNeill, Camara, Catennaci, Lipon, Subban.

Subban is gonna cause some controversy, but based on play so far this camp, he shouldn't make the team.

No chance.....McNeill have been one of the best forward the last 2 days while Watson was disapointing

DKQ · 12-12-2012, 07:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun Bisson

My final 8 cuts:

Dumba, Wotherspoon, Sproul, McNeill, Camara, Catennaci, Lipon, Subban.

Subban is gonna cause some controversy, but based on play so far this camp, he shouldn't make the team.

I would feel very unsure going into a tournament if our goalies were Binnington, Brossoit and Paterson.

js44 · 12-12-2012, 07:35 PM

My final 8 cuts :

Paterson, Murphy, Sproul, Whoterspoon, Camara, Catenacci, Wilson and Lipon.

Shaun Bisson · 12-12-2012, 07:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheGleninator

Who would be your starter and backup if you want to cut Subban?

I think Brossoit would start and Binnington would back up.

Just my opinion though.

HossTheBoss · 12-12-2012, 07:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun Bisson

My final 8 cuts:

Dumba, Wotherspoon, Sproul, McNeill, Camara, Catennaci, Lipon, Subban.

Subban is gonna cause some controversy, but based on play so far this camp, he shouldn't make the team.

Subban gives the team the best chance to win.. you can't make an argument for any of the other players, even though Binnington is having a strong season, there's a significant dropoff; it's Subban and everyone else. He's not getting cut, even if he let in 10 goals today.

And given who's left if camp, I don't see McNeill getting cut. Team Canada isn't bringing 3 draft eligible forwards. Period.

MrWangz · 12-12-2012, 07:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaun Bisson

My final 8 cuts:

Dumba, Wotherspoon, Sproul, McNeill, Camara, Catennaci, Lipon, Subban.

Subban is gonna cause some controversy, but based on play so far this camp, he shouldn't make the team.

Huh? Subban only played bad today. He wasn't too bad yesterday. Besides, he's probably the safest bet for Canada in net.