Huberdeau vs. Couturier

[Karma]

Sean Couturier put up better numbers in junior, had a good rookie NHL season and is doing well in the AHL while Huberdeau is/was dominating against juniors which Couturier would have done if he had went back anyway.

I'll take Couturier but Huberdeau does have a bit more offensive upside IMO but not enough to take him.

[Sasso09]

Originally Posted by Karma

Sean Couturier put up better numbers in junior, had a good rookie NHL season and is doing well in the AHL while Huberdeau is/was dominating against juniors which Couturier would have done if he had went back anyway.

I'll take Couturier but Huberdeau does have a bit more offensive upside IMO but not enough to take him.

This is how I see it... IMO Couturier was better at the draft and should of went before Huberdeau.. Since the draft Couturier made the Flyers Roster and was there best defensive forward.. Huberdeau failed to make the Panthers... I know everyone developers differently, but you would have to say Couturier dramatically raised his stock over Huberdeau thus far.

[Prairie Habs]

I voted Huberdeau but after thinking about I prefer Couturier. I don't think the difference on offense will be enough to cover Couterier's edge on the defensive side.

[lakai17]

Big Sean.

[theboss]

Originally Posted by lakai17

Big Sean.

Lil jon

[Howboutthempanthers]

Originally Posted by Sasso09

This is how I see it... IMO Couturier was better at the draft and should of went before Huberdeau.. Since the draft Couturier made the Flyers Roster and was there best defensive forward.. Huberdeau failed to make the Panthers... I know everyone developers differently, but you would have to say Couturier dramatically raised his stock over Huberdeau thus far.

Umm, Huberdeau was sent back to juniors last year because the Panthers wanted him to get a little bigger. If the decision was just based on performance alone he would have made the team last year.

[Lehner]

Easily Huberdeau

[Sasso09]

Originally Posted by Lehner

Easily Huberdeau

Yup and Z > both of them right??

[lakai17]

apparently it isn't too close to call though.

[Sasso09]

Originally Posted by lakai17

apparently it isn't too close to call though.

Lol yeah... Kind of funny how it's split with almost no " too close to calls"

[Sasso09]

If huberdeau was drafted this year instead of last he would fall out of the 1st round. His stock has dropped hard and Sean's has rose... I don't get how this is close.

[marioni]

Couturier