I dont think there is much room for many in the line up but here you go
Palmieri - 90% - Nothing left to prove in AHL
Guenin - 75% - 7th Defense
Maroon - 50% - 4th line
DSP - 30% - Needs to develop game more
Vatanen - 20% - Only if they need puck moving defense
Holland - 20% - Only if injury or season goes in the tank
Clark - 20% - Injury or 7th defense
McMillan - 10% - Depth player
Etem - 5% - Late season call up
Wagner - 5% - Depth player
Last edited by OCSportsfan: 02-05-2013 at 10:18 AM.
Reason: Since we have already started the season, lets change it to playing in the NHL
Your likelihood for Holland is a bit...well...wrong. He's a PPG player in a talent inflated AHL and Boudreau loves his game. He's probably the third most likely to get a spot on the team behind DSP and Palmieri.
I also think Lindholm would be more likely to get a call up right off the bat than Guenin. Hampus only came to NA because management let him think he'd have a shot to make the team out of camp.
I love Hollands game, I think he is a potential first line center, but unless something happens, I dont think he will play this year in the NHL. You can pencil him in for next year though.
As far as DSP, I like the way he plays also, but I think he played in the NHL last year because he could not go to the AHL. It was either the NHL or juniors and he would not have improved playing against kids.
I did not include Lindholm since they will go slow with him because the concussions. I think he could play this year, but he is too valuable to rush.
DSP, Holland and Palmieri are all close to locks IMO. Maroon has an outside chance also. Someone will need to take the 7th defenseman spot as well - I expect that to be a vet as they will be sitting in the pressbox every night - probably Smaby, Hendry or Guenin.
If Holland doesn't make the team then who are the 4 centers? And please don't tell me you think Cogliano is a realistic option at C. He's ****ing terrible there.
There you go. List me a better center than Holland. He looked plenty capable in his stint last season and Id argue that he improved quite a bit since then.
If Holland doesn't make the team then who are the 4 centers? And please don't tell me you think Cogliano is a realistic option at C. He's ****ing terrible there.
Unfortunately it is Cogliano unless Pellly or some Veteran face off guy is signed. Holland is a top 6 center, and although I would not be upset if they brought him up to play there, I just think they are going to go with
If Holland doesn't make the team then who are the 4 centers? And please don't tell me you think Cogliano is a realistic option at C. He's ****ing terrible there.
Your likelihood for Holland is a bit...well...wrong. He's a PPG player in a talent inflated AHL and Boudreau loves his game. He's probably the third most likely to get a spot on the team behind DSP and Palmieri.
I also think Lindholm would be more likely to get a call up right off the bat than Guenin. Hampus only came to NA because management let him think he'd have a shot to make the team out of camp.
They won't call Lindholm up to sit on the bench, so unless Beauchemin isn't healthy yet I agree Guenin as the #7 D is far more likely the first D call up. If/when Souray injures himself then its likely Lindholm gets a call.
I also think the only way Holland stays up is if either Bonino can't cut it as the 2a/2b center or if Holland goes back to tearing it up at the AHL level. I doubt they want him only getting 5-7 minutes of ice time when he could be further developing.
They won't call Lindholm up to sit on the bench, so unless Beauchemin isn't healthy yet I agree Guenin as the #7 D is far more likely the first D call up. If/when Souray injures himself then its likely Lindholm gets a call.
I also think the only way Holland stays up is if either Bonino can't cut it as the 2a/2b center or if Holland goes back to tearing it up at the AHL level. I doubt they want him only getting 5-7 minutes of ice time when he could be further developing.
Thankfully Beauchemin was fully recovered before training camp was meant to start, he's definitely ready as far as I know.
As for Holland, Boudreau did say he wants to roll 4 lines. Getzlaf and Perry played on the 4th line in 05-06 and still averaged around 12 mins a game due to getting a decent amount of PP time and the fact we actually had the depth to roll 4 lines that year.
Wagner works every shift and is a good player but Etem has really stepped it up and should be ahead of wags on the depth chart.
I don't disagree, but he hasn't opened up a major lead on Wagner, yet. So if we're calling Wagner a depth player, then Etem is the same. In truth, I don't think either are depth players. They just aren't ready for the show.
Pelly can barely handle himself in the AHL from what I've seen.
Agree completely. Pelly is a waste. Not physical enough and doesn't consistently bring enough energy to earn a spot IMO. I don't mind having a grinder on the 4th line, but he better be mixing it up, and IMO he's not consistent enough in that area. Don't waste a roster spot on him.
I dont think there is much room for many in the line up but here you go
Palmieri - 90% - Nothing left to prove in AHL
Guenin - 75% - 7th Defense
Maroon - 50% - 4th line
DSP - 30% - Needs to develop game more
Vatanen - 20% - Only if they need puck moving defense
Holland - 20% - Only if injury or season goes in the tank
Clark - 20% - Injury or 7th defense
McMillan - 10% - Depth player
Etem - 5% - Late season call up
Wagner - 5% - Depth player
I think I saw a Pig Fly, oh no wait that was Palmieri starting in the NHL, from the worst team in the AHL to the best team in the NHL LOL
