Other: *ALL* PK Subban talk (News/Speculation/Rumors/Proposals) ‎

[Hawkguy]

Originally Posted by Sloth Slothersons

Wow, just like everyone else, I'm surprised to find out that Hossa is 34. Plays like he's 28.

Maybe because he's missed so much time to injury that his body isn't broken.

[PensBeerGeek]

Originally Posted by Fizzz

Make that Letang and a 2nd and you have a deal!

If you aren't going to be serious, why not just ask for Crosby, Malkin, and a 1st?

[Maxpac]

Originally Posted by psupens

i wouldn't touch that trade with a 20-mile pole

Make that a 50 mile pole for Habs. Terrible value for a hig end defensmen like Subban.

[Le Magnifique 66]

Good player but I don't think it's a good idea to have PK in our locker room. I'd pass

[CharlesHabsFan]

Well we said we've been looking for a winger to play with Plekanec and Gionta. According to me, Hossa's the perfect one to complete that line.

But as we know, Galchenyuk is starting the season in Montreal and might end up just as good at that spot. No need to lose Subban at this point.

So, although I find that deal interesting, I'd be passing on that offer personally.

[BigBenSF]

I'd take PK with that deal (if you swapped Harrington with another player), Montreal fans wouldn't budge though.

[pld459666]

Originally Posted by MichiganWolverines

P.K. Subban is a talented defenseman, but his value is too much. Montrèal would want a player like James Neal in return.

that's the first name that came to my mind when i saw the thread.

Neal+ for Subban

Neal proved that he could produce with an elite level center.

Subban is already a top pairing defenceman.

Basically, I do not see a deal happening between the 2 teams.

[I Am Score*]

Replace Hossa with Leddy and they would consider it.

[Cradorium]

To : Vlasic+Demers

To : Subban+Weber

Thoughts?

[AJ SF4L]

I don't think either side does this. Subban is a great defenseman and Montreal would want massive overpayment before they even consider moving him. Even though they haven't signed him yet, they do not want to lose him.

As for the Sharks, Vlasic and Demers are key players in the Top 4 for the future, with Vlasic being Burns partner and Demers hopefully taking over for Boyle. I doubt they would want to jeopardize the team's future by trading both of them.

[ginovegas]

Subban, Plekanec , Gionta
for Kane and Bogosian

or

Subban, Plekanec, Gallagher or Kristo plus a 2nd. Maybe even through in Weber if Jets are short on right D

Flame away

[Vankiller Whale]

Jets get hosed here.

EDIT: Was Subban missing from the OP, or was I just blind? Closer value, but I still think the Jets decline.

[CanadienShark]

Those are my two favourite teams and I wouldn't do it from either perspective. MEL is perfect complement for San Jose's offensive defensemen, whereas Montreal needs PK's explosiveness and excitement. Demers has huge potential and is a major part of the Sharks future and Weber isn't needed. Vlasic just doesn't fit perfectly with Montreal and while Demers is nice, I'd prefer the risk-reward of Subban.

Neither side does it, however fair the value is. I love these teams equally, so I am unbiased.

[MillarWithASave]

I love Vlasic on the Sharks, I honestly think neither team does this, both need both plays too much to part with them.

[MillarWithASave]

Jets say no.

[Ragamuffin Gunner]

I wouldn't give that for PK as a Pens fan.

[KingBogo]

Not that this proposal is that bad and I'm a fan of Subban...But when was the last time a team traded their top 2 value players in a single trade?

[ginovegas]

Originally Posted by Vankiller Whale

Jets get hosed here.

EDIT: Was Subban missing from the OP, or was I just blind? Closer value, but I still think the Jets decline.

Subban was always there from beginning

[Frozenice]

As a Hab fan I'd want Pouliot and Harrington.

The thing is other teams would be willing to pay more and having better trading pieces that suit the Habs needs, better.

[capitalsrock]

Not bad

imo:

Subban=Bogosian

Plekanec+Gionta=Kane


Value is good but Jets won't do it just because:

-Kane+Bogosian aren't going anywhere anytime soon. Faces of the Franchise of the future

-They definitely do not need more 2nd line centers because they have plenty.

-Jets don't want aging forwards. They are looking for future players/young guys.

[Bourne Endeavor]

Not a bad deal but the Sharks need Vlasic's defensive game far more than the offense upside Subban would provide. Had they not dealt for Burns, I could see this having greater interest from their perspective. Montreal would likely refuse either way. Too much potential in Subban to move him.

[Montreal Shadow]

Originally Posted by Le Magnifique 66

Good player but I don't think it's a good idea to have PK in our locker room. I'd pass

You won't be in the locker room. How about you ask Montreal players what they think of him in the locker room? Oh you mean you don't know what they think? Why don't you want him in Pittsburgh's locker room then?

Ridiculous.

[magic school bus]

Throw in someone better than Weber and it's an easy yes for me.

[Leafs87]

Originally Posted by magic school bus

Throw in someone better than Weber and it's an easy yes for me.

Clearly the only problem is it becomes a easy no to the habs

[Nighthock]

SJ is not the place for huge egos ...