Trade Rumors and Free Agent TalkTrade rumors, transactions, and free agent talk. Rumors must contain the word RUMOR in post title. Proposals must contain the word PROPOSAL in post title.
To: Philly - Perry (not signed) and may be a deadline deal if Philly is playoff bound. Plus Anaheims first round pick. And Smith Pelly for your bottom two lines.
To Anaheim: Scott Hartnell + 2nd
First Anaheim needs grit upfront plus if we lose Getz, Koivu, Selanne in offseason due to UFA and retirement this is also to add, all a conclusion at deadline IF this is Anaheims scenario.
I think Anaheim and Philly are good trade partners thoughts? Add subtract as you wish.
I wouldn't do Perry for Hartnell straight up much less with a 1st Round Pick going to Anaheim. A more fair offer (but probably not a perfect one) would be:
Anaheim: S. Hartnell, S. Couturier & 1st Round Pick
I wouldn't do Perry for Hartnell straight up much less with a 1st Round Pick going to Anaheim. A more fair offer (but probably not a perfect one) would be:
Anaheim: S. Hartnell, S. Couturier & 1st Round Pick
Philly: C. Perry & K. Palmieri
First Perrys unsigned and IF wants out of Anaheim. And no Thee our first round picks going to you.
Wow one could argue that Smith-Pelly and Anaheim's first could be enough for Hartnell value wise. So adding Perry seems like a steel. With that being said I think Philly love Hartnell and sometimes a player just belings somewhere (Smyth in Edmonton) so I do not think they trade him.
No matter the return.
I wouldn't do Perry for Hartnell straight up much less with a 1st Round Pick going to Anaheim. A more fair offer (but probably not a perfect one) would be:
Anaheim: S. Hartnell, S. Couturier & 1st Round Pick
Philly: C. Perry & K. Palmieri
All that from Philly for a few months of Perry? Lol, you can't just ignore the contracts.
You're giving up WAY too much for Hartnell, I thought that much was clear.
Ehh it's a 1st round pick and Smith Pelly if Perry wants out. He's a 37 goal scorer with gritt upfront who is also healthy who's ALSO played all 82 game seasons 2 seasons in a row? How is this way to much explain to me?
Ehh it's a 1st round pick and Smith Pelly if Perry wants out. He's a 37 goal scorer with gritt upfront who is also healthy who's ALSO played all 82 game seasons 2 seasons in a row? How is this way to much explain to me?
Ehh it's a 1st round pick and Smith Pelly if Perry wants out. He's a 37 goal scorer with gritt upfront who is also healthy who's ALSO played all 82 game seasons 2 seasons in a row? How is this way to much explain to me?
Now you have completely lost me.
You proposed Perry + 1st + DSP
for
Hartnell + 2nd
I said Ducks give up way too much.
Now you're telling me how good Perry is which as a Ducks fan isn't news to me.
I'd like to know if Perry plans on testing free agency before the Flyers pursue him via trade. There's a good chance the Flyers will make a run at him if he makes it to free agency.
Value is good. I'd probably do it from a Flyers perspective
I'd like to know if Perry plans on testing free agency before the Flyers pursue him via trade. There's a good chance the Flyers will make a run at him if he makes it to free agency.
Value is good. I'd probably do it from a Flyers perspective
I think from an Anaheim perspective we would do it to. If perry wants out at deadline best believe we would deal him. And get max return. Plus losing a first with Anaheim being on a serious run at the moment our draft pick may be quite low in upcoming draft.
So lets say picking 22-30 first round? And losing Smith Pelly and losing Perry who wants out (hypothetical) for Hartnell and your 2nd while Philly does there playoff run? Seems good deal for both teams.
To: Philly - Perry (not signed) and may be a deadline deal if Philly is playoff bound. Plus Anaheims first round pick. And Smith Pelly for your bottom two lines.
To Anaheim: Scott Hartnell + 2nd
First Anaheim needs grit upfront plus if we lose Getz, Koivu, Selanne in offseason due to UFA and retirement this is also to add, all a conclusion at deadline IF this is Anaheims scenario.
I think Anaheim and Philly are good trade partners thoughts? Add subtract as you wish.
So if Anaheim expects to lose Getzlaf, Koivu and Selanne, then they will trade Perry to make Hartnell their teams centerpiece?
Typically team paying for the rental buy at a premium in these situaitons.
Sorry, 3 months of Perry is not greater than 6 years of Hartnell. If Perry wants out of Anaheim (and I'm not saying he does, keep in mind this whole thing was started by a Ducks fan), then Hartnell + a 2nd for an unsigned Perry + 1st is pretty decent value IMO. Maybe take Smith Pelly out.
But make no mistake, Scott Hartnell is an incredibly valuable player who every team in the NHL would love to acquire and the Flyers could get considerably more for him than just a 1st round pick (which is essentially what this boils down to if Perry walks).
Typically team paying for the rental buy at a premium in these situaitons.
Why? Have Perry who MAY want out and tells management that? = Trade Him
Were basically sending DSP and a first for a 37 goal scorer last season who's healthy as an ox. Also has played two FULL 82 games seasons, gritt upfront, can score, and can dominate our Ryan line. And in win now mode rather than a prospect for a few years hoping it can prosper.
I think from an Anaheim perspective we would do it to. If perry wants out at deadline best believe we would deal him. And get max return. Plus losing a first with Anaheim being on a serious run at the moment our draft pick may be quite low in upcoming draft.
So lets say picking 22-30 first round? And losing Smith Pelly and losing Perry who wants out (hypothetical) for Hartnell and your 2nd while Philly does there playoff run? Seems good deal for both teams.
Like I said, that is one DISASTROUS deal for Ducks. If Perry can't be signed, we can trade him alone for better package.
I like Hartnell but he's 31 in couple of months, he's signed for 6 more years at 4.75M cap hit, his career high is 67 points.
Wow, just wow. There's nothing to like about this deal from Ducks POV.
I also realized you were talking about Hartnell in your previous post, not Perry.
I'd like to know if Perry plans on testing free agency before the Flyers pursue him via trade. There's a good chance the Flyers will make a run at him if he makes it to free agency.
Value is good. I'd probably do it from a Flyers perspective
What if perry agrees to sign with your team laundry?
Why? Have Perry who MAY want out and tells management that? = Trade Him
Were basically sending DSP and a first for a 37 goal scorer last season who's healthy as an ox. Also has played two FULL 82 games seasons, gritt upfront, can score, and can dominate our Ryan line. And in win now mode rather than a prospect for a few years hoping it can prosper.
Im confused why are we trading our 1st(in a deep draft) and dsp + perry?
For a guy that who had a good year but could potentially go back to less then 50 point seasons away from giroux?
Ill pass... ill trade perry for a package of prospect/picks like kovalchuck/hossa and hope our scouts do a good job with the picks.
Please explain a better deal for Perry who will be unsigned if he wants out of Anaheim?
If you trade Perry at the deadline expect a first, a top prospect and 2nd/3rd liner coming your way at the very least. Perry is very well respected throughout the league and would make any top team a cup favorite.
