Palffy is the most skilled. He almost makes it LAPD by himself. Absolutely loved Deadmarsh. Allison was a load out on the ice too.
A Cup is a Cup, but I have to go with Allison/Deadmarsh/Palffy. However, because of the way Kopitar and Brown played in the playoffs leading a team to a Cup, it's closer than it would be if you asked this question prior to the playoffs last year.