HOH Top-40 Goalies Voter Record - Hawkey Town 18

[seventieslord]

Round 1 list

#	Name
1	Patrick Roy
2	Dominik Hasek
3	Jacques Plante
4	Terry Sawchuk
5	Glenn Hall
6	Martin Brodeur
7	Ken Dryden
8	Vladislav Tretiak
9	Frank Brimsek
10	Turk Broda
11	Clint Benedict
12	Bernie Parent
13	Johnny Bower
14	Ed Belfour
15	Charlie Gardiner
16	Bill Durnan
17	Georges Vezina
18	Jiri Holecek
19	Tony Esposito
20	Hugh Lehman
21	Billy Smith
22	Grant Fuhr
23	Tiny Thompson
24	Roy Worters
25	Hap Holmes
26	Gump Worsley
27	George Hainsworth
28	Harry Lumley
29	Tom Barrasso
30	Rogie Vachon
31	Chuck Rayner
32	Percy LeSueur
33	Paddy Moran
34	Ed Giacomin
35	John Vanbiesbrouck
36	Curtis Joseph
37	Riley Hern
38	Henrik Lundqvist
39	Tim Thomas
40	John Ross Roach
41	Al Rollins
42	Roberto Luongo
43	Mike Liut
44	Jiri Kralik
45	Pekka Lindmark
46	Dave Kerr
47	Gerry Cheevers
48	Miikka Kiprusoff
49	Chico Resch
50	John Bouse Hutton
51	Alec Connell
52	Lorne Chabot
53	Mike Richter
54	Mike Vernon
55	Tom Paton
56	Vladimir Dzurilla
57	Ron Hextall
58	Johnny Mowers
59	Roger Crozier
60	Don Edwards

Players on the top-40 not ranked:

None

Players on the top-40 ranked below #50:

Alec Connell (51)

Players exclusive to this list and no more than two others:

None

Players ranked highest on this list:

Paddy Moran (33)

Players ranked lowest on this list:

Ron Hextall (57)
Roger Crozier (59)
Don Edwards (60)

Hextall, Crozier and Edwards were left off of 10, 10 and 20 lists, respectively.

Round 2 voting record:

Round	1st	2nd	3rd	4th	5th	6th	7th	8th
1	Roy	Hasek	Plante	Hall	Brodeur	Sawchuk	Dryden
2	Brodeur	Sawchuk	Dryden	Tretiak	Brimsek	Benedict	Durnan	Broda
3	Brimsek	Gardiner	Vezina	Benedict	Broda	Belfour	Parent	Esposito
4	Broda	Belfour	Durnan	Worters	Holecek	Parent	Esposito	Bower
5	Worters	Holecek	Parent	Lehman	Bower	Fuhr	Smith	Thompson
6	Lehman	Thompson	Fuhr	Smith	Holmes	Hainsworth	Worsley	Lumley
7	Fuhr	Rayner	Barrasso	Lumley	Joseph	Holmes	Worsley	Vachon
8	Barrasso	LeSueur	Holmes	Joseph	Vanbiesbrouck	Luongo	Giacomin	Vachon
9	Lesueur	Vanbiesbrouck	Lundqvist	Luongo	Vachon	Kiprusoff	Thomas	Connell
10	Lundqvist	Liut	Thomas	Kiprusoff	Connell	Roach	Rollins	Cheevers

Round 2 Participation Record

Round	Rank	Posts
1	13	17
2	24	2
3	6	15
4	24	2
5	14	3
6	12	4
7	9	14
8	17	3
9	8	15
10	19	1
Total	13	76

[TheDevilMadeMe]

You really never bought Connell, did you?

[Dennis Bonvie]

Originally Posted by TheDevilMadeMe

You really never bought Connell, did you?

Athough he had him 5th in the last vote.

I think we were starting to reel Hawkey Town in at the end.

[TheDevilMadeMe]

I had a similarly high ranking of Paddy Moran (though not quite this high), but I would lower him now after information about LeSueur makes it seem like he was much more widely considered the best goalie of that era. I'd still have Moran as #2 for the era though.

[Mike Farkas]

Originally Posted by TheDevilMadeMe

You really never bought Connell, did you?

Keyword. He needed to be sold. Some didn't want to make a speculative purchase.

[Hawkey Town 18]

Originally Posted by TheDevilMadeMe

I had a similarly high ranking of Paddy Moran (though not quite this high), but I would lower him now after information about LeSueur makes it seem like he was much more widely considered the best goalie of that era. I'd still have Moran as #2 for the era though.

Same thing happened for me. As you can see, when I was making my Round 1 list I had the two about equal, but in Round 2 discussion it was made pretty clear that LeSueur was better.

[Hawkey Town 18]

Originally Posted by seventieslord

Round 2 voting record:

I feel I owe an explanation for my absence of Bill Durnan on my Round 2, Vote 3 rankings. He was suppose to be ranked after Broda in that vote, in the 6th position. I submitted my vote hastily and made a careless mistake. Fortunately, had my vote been cast as I intended, it would not have made a difference as to which 4 guys got in that round. Apologies for the error. I assure you that I was much more careful in the votes that followed and made sure I accounted for all candidates by listing those that didn't make my top 8 as "Not Rated," as the vote collectors can attest to.