Granted I have only made it through one thread but I am surprised I have not seen Doughty mentioned yet...Still have 6 more to go so I am sure I will see it...I am going to go with Chara on this one as we have yet to see how well Weber will be in a playoff setting without Suter.
Personally speaking, I'd want Weber on my team. Solid two way guy who is almost equal at both his offensive and defensive side. Chara is a close second but I'd take guys like Kronwall or Doughty over Karlsson. I just find the two way guys are just more valuable in the playoffs then the strong offensive guys like Karlsson
Did you really just use Kronwall's name in the same sentance as the others mentioned? WOW...Karlsson over Kronwall for any playoff run and its beyond AINEC.