I like something playing off the "fluke" theme, but maybe instead of "fluke", the theme is:
Animated GIF, first animation has some sort of image and some ridiculous stat like "10 Straight Road Victories" or "Defeated 1,2,3 Western Seeds" etc...
Then it goes to an image of a King holding the cup, probably Brown when he first hoisted it with, in large font "MEH". Also good here would be the Brown picture after the Roszival hit when he has his tongue sticking out laughing. If you chose a player instead of a specific stat, the picture would be said player holding the Cup.
Then last picture is whatever you want it to be while referencing 2013 Playoffs. Maybe that's the first one? I don't make GIFs so pardon the ignorance.
Possibility to get creative with the "stat" portion of it...could be cheeky like "Great Conversationalist" and have a shot of Brown/Doan in the handshake line etc..."Only in Blowouts" with Carter celebrating a SCF goal..."Fleeced" or "Bad CORSI" and have a pic of Richards..."Overrated" with Doughty..."Too Many Blondes" with Stoll etc...
I don't want to use the word fluke in the event they crash and burn in the 1st round. I'd prefer to either highlight one of the amazing stats they accomplished on the run or one of the negatives that is said about the run, team and/or specific players straight into a shot of the Cup being hoisted with "meh" just jumping out.
... but let's conveniently ignore that now because we don't want to acknowledge that I was right about your MS Paint skills.
You're entitled to your opinion, WRONG as it may be, because you seem to the be the only one that has a problem with my MSPaint skillz, everyone else seemed to want to rock them last year, and we won the cup with them, so